Quote from nkhoi:
anybody remember this?
It began with one of the century's strangest events: A "phantom battle" in the Gulf of Tonkin that enabled President Johnson to exact from Congress the total power to go to war.
...
Challenged later about the validity of the August 4 attack, McNamara called these intercepts "unimpeachable" evidence. Yet many intelligence officials are unconvinced.
http://www.usnews.com/usnews/news/articles/051203/3phantombattle.htm
but yes that was how VN War started... on a phantom battle.
you are absolutely correct.
mcnamara recently confirmed that these incidents were nothing more than occassional run ins with north vietnamese fishing boats and accidents but commanders further up the chain managed to convince washington that they were regularly being attacked.
hence the decision to up the ante and send the marines in.
the point mcnamara made in his recent documentary titled 'the fog of war' was that he felt the administration and the military were just waiting for any excuse to go in and the gulf of tonkin incidents gave them just that.
when asked did he feel personally responisble for sending so many us servicemen to their deaths in vietnam ( 58,000 over ten years) he had tears in his eyes and said not a day goes by when he regrets what happened.
apparently he continually pressed the case not for war inside the administration but was always over ruled.
on the outside he had to play along.he was a very intelligent businessman and most of the media knew that he felt the war was wrong from the very beginning and completely un-winnable.
i think the same is true today.
everyone knows at some point there will be a major confrontation with iran and that when push comes tp shove the americans will inevitably not back down.
america needs an enemy to survive.
sadly for iran they just stepped up as the most likely candidate.