Clueless Trump

Quote from Free Thinker:

why are high grain prices, a commodity the us exports, good and high oil prices,a commodity the middle east exports, bad?
High grain prices are caused by market conditions, high oil prices are caused by the fact that only a small number of countries have oil and they deliberately collude and cut production to keep prices artificially high. In other words, the price of grain is driven by free market, the price of oil is de-facto set by a monopoly.
 
Quote from OPTIONAL777:

We are to blame for that, not OPEC.
We are to blame for what we've done wrong, they are to blame for what they are doing wrong (price gouging etc).

The best way to kill a snake is to remove its food source.

We focus on something positive, i.e. energy independence. The rest takes care of itself. Focusing on trying to control the snake is stupidity.

You don't blame the snake for biting you when you know it is a snake
Yep, you just cut its head off. And that's what Trump is proposing.

Trump can't cut off OPEC's head. He has no leverage. The only real leverage is to become energy independent. All focus and energy in that direction solves the problem. OPEC is a symptom, not the cause. We are the cause of our own problem, because we did not take steps 30+ years ago to become fully self sufficient.


The solution is energy independence. That could happen in a very short time, if we all decided to make it happen together.
But until it happens we might still cut the snake's head off, we'll have more cash left to actually invest in energy independence and there'll be one less disgusting snake in the world.

No, we put 100% of our attention on the real solution to the real problem. OPEC is not the real problem, so wasting time with OPEC is not the real solution.

Every time we avoid a problem, the more the problem grows.

1. Remove all troops from the middle east, period.
2. Mandate solar and natural gas for all government building and vehicles.
3. Open unlimited drilling of oil for 3 years.
4. Put the troops who come home on our borders to secure, convert weapons production to the conversion of automobiles to natural gas.


OPEC, who gives a shit when we don't need them.

I say to hell with the entire middle east, let them nuke themselves.

If we didn't need OPEC, we wouldn't care about them...so the goal and the number one focus and all our energy needs to be diverted to not needing OPEC.

Israel? Stop funding them, they can take care of themselves. If they want to live in that shit hole part of the world, that's their fault, not ours.
Hmm, sounds good... except for the fact that most of us live in the real world in which both republicans and democrats are doing absolutely nothing about energy independence. And even if they start today it'll take decades anyway.

Perhaps in your utopian universe if there is a theorecical solution to a problem that may take decades and trillions to implement, no practical steps need to be taken to imporove the situation today. But I'd rather give Trump a chance to lean on OPEC now while we are all waiting for your utopian dream to come true. Stop pretending that these are two mutually exclusive solutions, putting heavy pressure on OPEC and working on energy indepence at the same time is the right way to proceed.
 
Quote from a_person:

High grain prices are caused by market conditions, high oil prices are caused by the fact that only a small number of countries have oil and they deliberately collude and cut production to keep prices artificially high. In other words, the price of grain is driven by free market, the price of oil is de-facto set by a monopoly.

nonsense. there are plenty of countries that ignore opec and do their own thing.
speculators in the us have more to do with the price of gas that opec does. there is no shortage of crude on the market.
 
I live in the real world, and know that neither side is doing anything about the problem.

So I should not talk about what we should do?

I am not suggesting an independent candidate who will do what we need to do?

It really is up to the voters to stop the insanity...voters do have the power, as much as they don't think they do.

Trump has no leverage on OPEC.

Tell me exactly, and be specific, what Trump could do to get OPEC to do what we want?


Quote from a_person:

Hmm, sounds good... except for the fact that most of us live in the real world in which both republicans and democrats are doing absolutely nothing about energy independence. And even if they start today it'll take decades anyway.

Perhaps in your utopian universe if there is a theorecical solution to a problem that may take decades and trillions to implement, no practical steps need to be taken to imporove the situation today. But I'd rather give Trump a chance to lean on OPEC now while we are all waiting for your utopian dream to come true. Stop pretending that these are two mutually exclusive solutions, putting heavy pressure on OPEC and working on energy indepence at the same time is the right way to proceed.
 
Quote from OPTIONAL777:

I live in the real world, and know that neither side is doing anything about the problem. So I should not talk about what we should do?
You don't live in a real world if knowing full well that neither side is working on a long term solution (which would take decades/billions to implement anyway), you still object to a proposal to do something about it today.

Trump has no leverage on OPEC. Tell me exactly, and be specific, what Trump could do to get OPEC to do what we want?
Trump can drill, bomb, intimidate, bribe, release strategic oil reserves, convince, prosecute, plot a coup, boycott, divest etc, any combination of the above in no particular order. The president of the only super power does have leverage.
 
Quote from a_person:

I live in the real world, and know that neither side is doing anything about the problem. So I should not talk about what we should do?
You don't live in a real world if knowing full well that neither side is working on a long term solution (which would take decades/billions to implement anyway), you still object to a proposal to do something about it today.


I know neither side is doing anything, that is the real world, and I live in it...that's why I am pushing for a change...not putting my head in the sand and admitting defeat.


Trump has no leverage on OPEC. Tell me exactly, and be specific, what Trump could do to get OPEC to do what we want?
Trump can drill, bomb, intimidate, bribe, release strategic oil reserves, convince, prosecute, plot a coup, boycott, divest etc, any combination of the above in no particular order. The president of the only super power does have leverage.


Bribe OPEC with what? You do know bribery is illegal, right?

Trump can bomb OPEC for not lowering prices?

Oh, that would work out very well....
 
Quote from OPTIONAL777:

I know neither side is doing anything, that is the real world, and I live in it...that's why I am pushing for a change...not putting my head in the sand and admitting defeat.
Did it ever occur to you that you can push for 2 things simultaniously - long term energy independence and short term solution of increasing oil production and lowering prices. Your attempts to present it as an "either or" choice are disingenuous, it's a false dilemma.
 
You can dilute your efforts if you want.

I think all the attention goes to the solution, not the symptoms.

If we attack the problem on the level of the solution, the symptoms will take care of themselves.

Quote from a_person:

I know neither side is doing anything, that is the real world, and I live in it...that's why I am pushing for a change...not putting my head in the sand and admitting defeat.
Did it ever occur to you that you can push for 2 things simultaniously - long term energy independence and short term solution of increasing oil production and lowering prices. Your attempts to present it as an "either or" choice are disingenuous, it's a false dilemma.
 
Quote from Free Thinker:

why are high grain prices, a commodity the us exports, good and high oil prices,a commodity the middle east exports, bad?
Because the US imports that high priced oil?
 
Back
Top