If you believe (a big if) the shorts, the removal in CC from the S&P will prompt institutional selling (Philip Morris will replace CC on the S&P).
Look, I'm biased, as I'm long CC, so take whatever I say with an even larger grain of salt than usually.
However, of all retail segments, I like electronics the most. In the electronics segment, BBY is the clear leader, and Radio Shack is the clear laggard, and CC is this strange entity that generates a lot of revenue, has no debt, and is currently experiencing a proxy battle for control of the board (and to oust the current CEO). So, it's a very foggy picture - but they do not have a revenue issue, which is a huge positive, IMO.
It's up more than most retailers since the beginning of 08, and its fundamentals are not exactly terrible (in fact, it trades at .05 p/s ratio, with a large cash reserve that makes the current share price close to cash value, let alone book value ($4.37 share price, with a net cash per share price of $2.50 - that's relatively remarkable).
I'm not a fan of S&P, but I think this research note is relatively accurate:
S&P Analyst Research Notes
S&P REITERATES BUY RECOMMENDATION ON SHARES OF CIRCUIT CITY
Friday 03/14/2008 11:37 AM ET
Ahead of Feb-Q results to be reported on 4/9, we are widening our Feb-Q loss estimate to $0.09 from $0.02. For FY 09 (Feb.), we project a slowdown in consumer spending and believe CC will be hard pressed to improve operating results. We are widening our FY 09 loss estimate to $0.91 from our previous loss estimate of $0.25, and cutting our DCF-based target price by $1 to $7. However, with net cash of nearly $2.50/share, significant opportunity for structural change, and trading at a trough price/sales ratio of 0.05X, we find the shares attractive at current levels.
I am staying long and hopefully not wrong CC. The move from the S&P isn't particularly worrisome to me as some of my best performers have been non-participants.
A big loss is expected. If they exceed the low expectations the street has baked into their cake, there could be a lot of upside for CC.
But it's all very fluid right now.