In all fairness china does siphon hundreds of billions a year through trade. I'd be willing to bet a good chunk of the stuff that USA imports from China is pure junk that does nothing to better the lives of Americans.
This is one experiment I would like to see happen. Even if Trump is wrong and it makes everything worse I'm a believer in trying it and see what happens. I love the volatility it causes too.
We're in a throwaway society. Let the experiment begin. Acquire less "things" but those you do be of higher quality, last longer. The trade war has already been waged for decades. Time for the U.S. to wake up and correct the unfair practices. (jmho)