Cbot Down!!!

Quote from whitster:

i can't believe all this whining

again, you can OFFSET your positions when CBOT is closed by using DIA or by using ES

exchanges going down is part of trading

if you do not have a risk management plan to deal with these things then you should not be trading.

trading is about DEFINING risk

the post about "it averages out over time" is absurd and shows a misunderstanding of risk

the point isn't that you should hope for the best due to law of averages. the point is that you protect capital

you simply watch DIA or NYSE:$INDU when YM is down and when your target was met on the short, you go long one ES or 500 DIA to hedge neutral

simple. and you should have this stuff planned before you trade.

losing traders blame others. professionals take responsibility


the issue came down to whther the stop loss executed or not - you cant hedge if you dont know that

now i know

so take your hands off your hips and quit scolding

you're not here to help, you're here because you're the kind of guy who can never pass up the chance to be a jerk
 
Quote from austinp:

In my time of trading, the CME has been down once. During that period of years, the CBOT has been down at least six - seven times.

One major reason why I don't trade anything on the CBOT... too bush league for me.

over the last year when I have been looking at the YM, it's been down like 3 times

I've never had such issues with other markets...
 
Quote from LT701:

the issue came down to whther the stop loss executed or not - you cant hedge if you dont know that

now i know

so take your hands off your hips and quit scolding

you're not here to help, you're here because you're the kind of guy who can never pass up the chance to be a jerk

Sucks what happened to you mate.

I work IT in the futures broking section of a large London bank and I can say for sure that the eCBOT is the worse exchange we deal with.

Also agree about the jerk thing.
 
Hum not only did this screw up my charts intraday. It looks like the daily chart is screwed up as well. At least mine is, looks like yesterday bar is gone, and I use CQG.
 
Quote from myminitrading:

Hum not only did this screw up my charts intraday. It looks like the daily chart is screwed up as well. At least mine is, looks like yesterday bar is gone, and I use CQG.

The daily chart is fine, my mistake.
 
Quote from LT701:

well, the stop executed as soon as it came back up, 54 points below where it was set

piece of *&^%ing %^&# ecbot

LT,

Not meaning to add salt to the wound, but did you ever find out where your stop was sitting? Only GTC orders, according to the CBOT PR would have been executed when it came back up. All day orders were cancelled. So, was the order GTC sitting at the exchange, or was it sitting on your brokers (IB) servers? I think it's a very important question.

Good trading to you
Osorico

BTW; to anyone using a platform that holds stops on YOUR local computer, this is exactly what would happen if YOUR computer goes down, and subsequently comes back up. Something to be aware of, regardless of exchange, or exchange going down.
 
Not to add insult to injury, but how does it make you feel to watch the price trade back up to just about were it was before the outage.

It would feel better if price was much lower from were your stop was executed.

I know the market always trys and make you feel like a fool. I know from experience.
 
<i>"over the last year when I have been looking at the YM, it's been down like 3 times

I've never had such issues with other markets..."</i>

Back in Jan 2004 I was running money in 30yr bonds. Had +/- 40 contracts on along with my own. Had a short trade working +'8 ticks in favor with stop at -'8 ticks to protect, or 16' tick spread heading into jobless claims, not even employment situation drivel.

Half the CBOT trunks went down in the volume surge, half didn't. My stop order was not routed thru the system, as stops weren't (aren't?) resident on the exchange. Trade was filled in the pit at -'40 ticks from entry, or -'32 ticks worse than stop-loss order staged to protect.

Incidentally, that was nearly highs for the day before it relaxed lower -'16 or so.

*

I quit trading CBOT products and immediately switched to GBPUSD, then ER2 a few months later. The CBOT has dropped at least six times since, if not more.

It always offers easy pickin's for the CME traders as they press the trapped YM players for a painful squeeze. Today was no different with the late morning drop.
 
Back
Top