Capitalism vs Socialism

Quote from piezoe:

In the USA you'll seldom hear someone extoll their own perceived virtues of socialism; yet it is clear to me from the facts, and present day examples we have all around us, that the jury may have already reached a conclusion quite different from yours or Mr. Churchill's. To give Sir Winston his due, however, we can't know exactly what Mr. Churchill's meant by "socialism" in the context of his remark, and it's too late to ask him.

All of the "isms", including corporatism, which, if you like, is a form of capitalism, have virtues and defects, though any virtue in either communism or corporatism isn't that obvious. If we just take the present examples available to us, it seems that the countries that are far more socialist than the US; yet have done a better job of maintaining a competitive, capitalist business environment and avoided becoming mired in U.S style corporate welfare are, if we are to judge by the universal attributes of living standards, health, education, personal freedom, crime and poverty, doing the best overall.
well piezoe, this is where you and I part company. But thank you for putting forth the progressive point of view. I'm already powerful enough, I don't need the government to help me. And I'm just about powerful enough that they should tame me down a little. I care about the poor, but I'll help them myself, one by one if you don't mind, and I can't help them with you constantly on my back. Now you go do your thinking and I'll go do my making, and we'll get along fine.
 
Quote from oldtime:

well piezoe, this is where you and I part company. But thank you for putting forth the progressive point of view. I'm already powerful enough, I don't need the government to help me. And I'm just about powerful enough that they should tame me down a little. I care about the poor, but I'll help them myself, one by one if you don't mind, and I can't help them with you constantly on my back. Now you go do your thinking and I'll go do my making, and we'll get along fine.

Oldtime, your remark reminds me of a remark attributed to Richard Nixon, likely apocryphal: "What unemployment are you talking about? All my friends are working." :D
 
Quote from piezoe:

Oldtime, your remark reminds me of a remark attributed to Richard Nixon, likely apocryphal: "What unemployment are you talking about? All my friends are working." :D
that's the thing about those apocryphals, you never know for sure
 
Back
Top