Can the tiny house movement end homelessness?

Thank you for making my point so well for me. You just posted a link to a google search for "multi generational welfare statistics" (thank you, I had no idea how to use Google). When I click the very first link on the search results, an article in the right leaning National Review magazine, the first two sentences of the resulting article are:
"Does parents’ depending on welfare create welfare dependency in their children? It’s an important question, but there is very little evidence out there on it."!!! It goes on to confirm exactly what I've been saying here. There's very little evidence and the best evidence of they could come up with was the results of a Norwegian study. And this is William F. Buckley's National Review!

Seriously, why do you believe what you do? I used to think along lines that were very similar to yours. My family and those around me just passed on as fact to me that we'd all be fine in this country except for those lazy welfare people who spent their whole life living off our hard work. Then I actually got to know some of those allegedly lazy welfare people. And started looking at the actual laws and statistics. And came to realize that what I had believed wasn't based on any objective facts, I'd just always believed it and never been forced to confront the basis for my belief. When I realized that there was no basis for my prior belief, and both anecdotal and data based evidence in fact showed the contrary, I changed my view on the subject. You know, kind of the scientific method, basis of pretty much all knowledge over the last couple hundred years.
Have you thought about why you believe what you do? Do you know why you are so sure that there are all these people out there? Have you ever even stopped to really think about the basis for your belief, or do you just believe it and when challenged you try to go find evidence to support that prior belief even though you only fell into it originally? Is that really the best way to view the world?
 
Most folks support a safety-net for those in genuine need, but are enraged by abuses. That's really the bottom line.
I'm with you on that, I'm as enraged as anyone. The point being that the Arnie's of the world believe that there is a significant portion of the population abusing this system with generations living their entire lifetime on welfare, and the truth is that the abuses are rare and generally prosecuted when found, and there are in fact not generations of people living their entire lifetime on welfare.
 
"
At a Brooklyn Bodega,
a Secret Shelter for the Homeless

For the last 14 years, Candido Arcángel has quietly taken in the homeless, allowing them to stay in a crude shelter in the store’s cellar."

It leads to a cavern where, for the past 14 years, the bodega owner has quietly housed scores of homeless men, some with violent pasts and mental illness. He takes them in, from local park benches and street corners, unable to bear the idea of anyone out in the cold.

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/10/nyregion/homeless-shelter-bodega-nyc-brooklyn.html

Mr. Arcángel is certainly not the first person to harbor the homeless in an untraditional setting. In Chicago last week, a man agreed to stop allowing homeless people to stay in his basement during frigid nights; in Brooklyn, a woman who had been sheltering the homeless in her home for decades eventually became the inspiration for a play, “Queen of Chesed,” that debuted last year.

Because Mr. Arcángel’s makeshift shelter is likely illegal, he asked that the precise location and name of his store not be disclosed. Between six and a dozen people live in the basement at any given time, he said.

There are a few rules: Men must be in for the night when the bodega closes at around 10 p.m.; after that, they may leave, but cannot return until the shop opens at 8 a.m. Mr. Arcángel does not charge a fee, and he pays for whatever electricity is used by the men, which he estimates costs him about $400 a month. It powers the lights, a hot plate and a large-screen television someone found on a street corner and lugged inside.

 
Last edited:
Thank you for making my point so well for me. You just posted a link to a google search for "multi generational welfare statistics" (thank you, I had no idea how to use Google). When I click the very first link on the search results, an article in the right leaning National Review magazine, the first two sentences of the resulting article are:
"Does parents’ depending on welfare create welfare dependency in their children? It’s an important question, but there is very little evidence out there on it."!!! It goes on to confirm exactly what I've been saying here. There's very little evidence and the best evidence of they could come up with was the results of a Norwegian study. And this is William F. Buckley's National Review!

Seriously, why do you believe what you do? I used to think along lines that were very similar to yours. My family and those around me just passed on as fact to me that we'd all be fine in this country except for those lazy welfare people who spent their whole life living off our hard work. Then I actually got to know some of those allegedly lazy welfare people. And started looking at the actual laws and statistics. And came to realize that what I had believed wasn't based on any objective facts, I'd just always believed it and never been forced to confront the basis for my belief. When I realized that there was no basis for my prior belief, and both anecdotal and data based evidence in fact showed the contrary, I changed my view on the subject. You know, kind of the scientific method, basis of pretty much all knowledge over the last couple hundred years.
Have you thought about why you believe what you do? Do you know why you are so sure that there are all these people out there? Have you ever even stopped to really think about the basis for your belief, or do you just believe it and when challenged you try to go find evidence to support that prior belief even though you only fell into it originally? Is that really the best way to view the world?

Perhaps, homelessness is an extremely challenging issue - as for every individual cases, "We come to realize that the “homeless” have a history and a complexity beyond what we see on the surface. "




http://labyrinthstageproductions.ca/queen-of-chesed/

This play has multiple layers to it. There is a gradual unfolding of the unique characters. They are not what they appear to be. We come to realize that the “homeless” have a history and a complexity beyond what we see on the surface. They have been able to forge meaningful relationships with each other. Compassion, cohesiveness, conflict and humour co-exist.
 
Last edited:
I agree Nitro those tiny homes are cool,but lots of cities wont even allow the homeless to pitch a tent. They are also passing laws forbidding even church groups from feeding the poor because that tends to make them stick around equating people with nuisance animals like squirrels or other vermin. Some church groups were ticketed and fined. Isn't drug abuse and mental health issues the number one reason though for homelessness?


Agreed. The cause of homelessness is not a shortage of small homes.
 
Federal reforms in 1996 eliminated the entitlement to welfare and limited benefits to a maximum of five years in a lifetime. States can exempt up to 20 percent of their caseload from the federal time limit. Moreover, they can extend the time limit beyond five years, as long as benefits are paid with state dollars.
%% Good read; + if we count corp welfare[ tax breaks, farm products support, oil drilling breaks, mortgage deduction.....] most of USa gets some kind of welfare. Taxes change , they killed the prop tax write off in NY....... somewhat, last tax bill i think:caution::cool:
 
I think I read somewhere that they are using old shipping containers as homes for the homeless.
They could call it shit hole city.
 
Perhaps, homelessness is an extremely challenging issue - as for every individual cases, "We come to realize that the “homeless” have a history and a complexity beyond what we see on the surface. "

Without any knowledge of getting help, a kid escaped from this home-school family could easily become homeless living with great fear.

The daughter's acts this time is just like a miracle, imo.

http://www.theage.com.au/world/turp...ors-escape-for-two-years-20180118-h0kppy.html

January 19 2018 - 10:00AM

Turpin daughter planned California 'House of Horrors' escape for two years

1516327019713.jpg


" The horrific scene was discovered on Sunday when the 17-year-old girl escaped by climbing out a window of the house, in Perris, and calling police from a disconnected mobile phone."
 
Last edited:
Back
Top