Can one choose to not settle an ITM option at expiry?

Ah ok that helps. I thought that auto-close meant auto-settle in ca$h. They actually deliver the shares.

It's not like oil or gold; no, they will not drive up to your house with an armored truck with bullion or tanker with oil.

I'm still not sure if I can let an ITM option expire--with neither cash settlement nor execution. Just let it die; no payment, no shares.

As others have pointed out: yes, it's possible; no, we can't tell you how, you have to call your broker; and don't do it for tax reasons, because that's misunderstanding tax law.
 
and you forgot one thing: it's stupid in a really big way just sell the call at the last day ... everything is better than to really throw money away ...
 
This remains one of the most stupid threads I recently seen on ET. Like I said before just sell the option the last day and you don't get any kind of trouble like this ...[/QUOTe

Exactly.
 
That's not how this works. That's not how any of this works. Please consult with a tax accountant before making these decisions.

Only dollars you make *over* $249.000 would be taxed at 40%.

You assume everyone lives in a margin tax rate area/territory. Germany, for example, has a progressive tax rate, where this might be a possibility (although the jump would be 1% not 7%)
 
You assume everyone lives in a margin tax rate area/territory. Germany, for example, has a progressive tax rate, where this might be a possibility (although the jump would be 1% not 7%)

I'm not sure the German tax system is very different from the U.S. in this regard. But either way, OP used $ in his example, so I think it was safe to assume.
 
I'm not sure the German tax system is very different from the U.S. in this regard. But either way, OP used $ in his example, so I think it was safe to assume.
I'm the OP, and no, it's not safe to assume. There are many different tax systems, and use of the dollar sign does not imply the US tax system.

The question is not about tax anyway, it's about allowing ITM contracts to expire.
 
You have to check with your broker for their specific rules on this.

Interactive Brokers allows contrary instructions. I'd guess that many other brokers do, as well.

Here's a scenario where you might want to do this.

Say you are long 10 ITM calls at expiry and short 1000s to offset the exercise.

The UL tanks AH below the calls' strike.

It is to your advantage to send contrary instructions and cover the shares.
 
I'm the OP, and no, it's not safe to assume. There are many different tax systems, and use of the dollar sign does not imply the US tax system.

The question is not about tax anyway, it's about allowing ITM contracts to expire.

Fair enough. Like we mentioned before, yes, it's possible, and yes, you'll need to talk to your broker.
 
Ah ok that helps. I thought that auto-close meant auto-settle in ca$h. They actually deliver the shares.

It's not like oil or gold; no, they will not drive up to your house with an armored truck with bullion or tanker with oil.

I'm still not sure if I can let an ITM option expire--with neither cash settlement nor execution. Just let it die; no payment, no shares.
Some options cash settle, SPX for example. I believe all single stock options settle with delivery though.
 
Back
Top