Can a simple trading system work?

Quote from runningman:

Many of the systems people post here seem very complicated, with filters, indicators, etc. My question is - can a simple system of, say a 5/50 MA crossover, buy when the 5 crosses the 50 going up, sell when the 5 crosses the 50 going down, on a 5 min chart- work? Is money management the key?

You need to ask yourself, "What is the larger trend?" Going long with the above, if the larger trend in the stock AND the market is down, you are going to be in trouble. This would likely be more of a shorting opportunity. This is why any MA system on its own is headed for failure without incorporating other considerations.
 
Yes - simple is alwyas better because it's easier to manage and easier to follow.

However, this doesn't mean doing a, say, 9/18 MA, and expecting it to work from 1934-2050.

You have to through in optimizations, money management, and some common sense.
 
Quote from Reaver:

Yes. I think that would work, with MM worked out.....

I don't know about 5-50, as the chart above illustrates, could make you miss out because of the large amount of difference in the time periods.....but you may could try some different numbers....

I wouldn't use MA's as a strict entry/exit system, but if you were to say use it to gauge short, medium, long term momentum....then at that point, you could have a very good method.......

Again, money management and a business-like approach is key.

P.S. What time frame would you be looking at trading?


Lookint at 5 min charts- I think its also important to have a rule that adds to winners as the trade goes the right way, but then it starts to complicate the process. I think the simplest solution is almost always best, so that's the trading method that would be right for my personality.
 
Quote from jjrvat:

Simple ideas work as long as you dont forget price analysis !!!

jjrvat

87iyp0j.png

Hi

Could you please describe this simple idea in words?

Thanks
 
Back
Top