Calls to defund police?! Wtf epic fail

Fine. Cut the police in the big cities.

That is a self-correcting situation. Police cut or abolished. Freakish crime levels develop like something out of purge movie. Politicians are recalled or voted out. Police force is restored.

The experiment won't affect the rest of us. Minneapolis might be called the "Unadministrated Area Formerly Known as Minneapolis" and be walled off while it is lawless.

I don't care what happens in these places. The people voted for those who will destroy their lives. Votes have consequences.

Leftist pols think cutting the police will virtue signal them to safety. The criminals will be so grateful for their benevolence that they will just give up crime overnight and be transformed into peaceful responsible citizens working in harmony with the community. The power of magical thinking.

Or, the residents and business owners will arm themselves, and crime will drop.
 
I have no problem with police being armed. I think unarmed police are a weakness and we've seen it time and time again in the UK.

The problem, as you so succinctly pointed out, is the lack of training the police get. Concealed carry holders in America are approximately as armed as police and the homicide rate for licensed CCW holders is several dozen orders of magnitude smaller than the police. It turns out having accountability when you carry a weapon is important. The "city is fallujah" mentality of modern American police. De-escalation is never an option. Even a traffic stop turns dicey if you reach too soon. To drive home how ridiculous this is urban dwelling Americans of all colors are taught the "rules" of dealing with the police in a traffic stop:

1. Have your ID and documents ready
2. Hands securely on the steering wheel with documents in hand
3. Roll down the windows and do not admit anything
4. Whatever you do - do not move until ordered to. Move slowly and deliberately and make sure your hands are visible at all times.

Lord help you if you are coming home from the range, having a medical crisis, or mentally unwell.

These "rules of engagement" citizens have to know shouldn't be the case. They're derived from decades of police violence that victimize otherwise innocent Americans. Americans understand every time the police stop your car it could be your last day on Earth. For some reason civilians are expected to remain calm with a gun in their face. Yet these victimizers are supposed to be "heroes"? A strange divergence from reality.

The solution is obvious. Policing requires at least a 2 year theoretical degree in law enforcement and 6-8 months of on the job (unarmed) training, bi-annual psychological evaluations by independent psychologists, and immediate dismissal if they are failed. The standard must be raised much higher. As one protester pointed out barbers go to school for longer than police.
Good post. I don't get pulled over often but when I do I roll down my window and hang both hands out the window until the cop is up on me and then I tell them I'm going for my wallet. You won't get shot in LA if you do that, its expected.

Requiring a 2 year law enforcement degree and subsequent certification is going to be called racist in the USA (academic requirements are problematic) but it is a great idea.

You have to pay cops better for that of course. There is a need for a higher ratio of sergeants and for those sergeants to be out with their officers. I feel like an older experienced cop might have stopped that murder. That crew was all young.

The academy system is supposed to address all of this but it doesn't seem to instill the basic idea that you cannot choke people. No choke holds. No choke pins. No baton chokes. So basic.
 
Last edited:
well, we have a control group now:
https://www.latimes.com/california/...etti-lapd-budget-cuts-10000-officers-protests

Mayor Eric Garcetti said he will direct $250 million to youth jobs, health initiatives and “peace centers” to heal trauma, and will allow those who have suffered discrimination to collect damages.
The money will have to be cut from other city operations; Garcetti, backed by City Council President Nury Martinez and his new Police Commission president, said as much as $150 million would come from the Los Angeles Police Department.
 
You'd think people who save lives (Nurses, Doctors, EMTs, Firefighters) would be the actual heroes. Or teachers who have to put up with your snot nosed entitled brat for hours every single day for less pay than a starbucks manager.

American hero worship is more of a cult. As an American I don't really understand it at all. But hey, if you want to lick the boot of someone who would club you to death for interrupting their lunch who am I stop you and your cult from doing it.

This is a bit hyperbolic, isn't it? Club you to death for interrupting their lunch?

So much of what you write is grounded in common sense and intelligent thought. Don't ruin it with over the top statements that are clearly ridiculous and incendiary.
 
I have no problem with police being armed. I think unarmed police are a weakness and we've seen it time and time again in the UK.

The problem, as you so succinctly pointed out, is the lack of training the police get. Concealed carry holders in America are approximately as armed as police and the homicide rate for licensed CCW holders is several dozen orders of magnitude smaller than the police. It turns out having accountability when you carry a weapon is important.

As a CCW holder and one who carries everywhere, this comparison ignores the fact that CCW holders aren't compelled to respond to calls for help, aren't dispatched into situations where they would have to encounter the same things as police. No civilian CCW holder has to make traffic stops, or enter a domestic dispute. So you can't really use this as any relevance at all.

The "city is fallujah" mentality of modern American police. De-escalation is never an option. Even a traffic stop turns dicey if you reach too soon. To drive home how ridiculous this is urban dwelling Americans of all colors are taught the "rules" of dealing with the police in a traffic stop:

1. Have your ID and documents ready
2. Hands securely on the steering wheel with documents in hand
3. Roll down the windows and do not admit anything
4. Whatever you do - do not move until ordered to. Move slowly and deliberately and make sure your hands are visible at all times.

Lord help you if you are coming home from the range, having a medical crisis, or mentally unwell.

Coming home from the range? Whenever I have been stopped by police officers I have never had a single problem. Ever. Hands on the wheel, polite conversation. Even when I was carrying and the cop knew I was carrying (because I told him).

I know you said you are American, but you now live in the UK, did I read this right? Just curious because I'm wondering when you last lived in the US and were puled over by a police officer. Because it sounds like you're getting a lot of your info from the media. Happy to admit if I am wrong.

The solution is obvious. Policing requires at least a 2 year theoretical degree in law enforcement and 6-8 months of on the job (unarmed) training, bi-annual psychological evaluations by independent psychologists, and immediate dismissal if they are failed. The standard must be raised much higher. As one protester pointed out barbers go to school for longer than police.

This is an excellent suggestion. Also consider pay raises and you'll get better people to risk their life for their job day in and out.
 
Police could use some better training, no doubt. However, watching your partner murder a man in the street doesn't require a law degree to know that's not right. That's not a lack of knowledge problem, it's a lack of discipline problem. A lack of accountability problem. A lack of leadership problem.
Go out to violent situations unarmed while training? Nope. Not going into that without the ability to defend myself. Better and more extensive training at the academy, better leadership, more accountability is the answer.
Pysch exams before, during and after? Yep, for sure.
Better pay? Absolutely, but that is no guarantee either. Again, more accountability and kill the we got each others back no matter what philosophy. You break the law, we as a unit throw your ass out.
As a helpful tip for would be hoodlums. Try not breaking the law for awhile. Should you choose to break the law and have the misfortune of getting caught, try not running your fuckin mouth and just surrender without resistance. This alone will greatly improve your chances of surviving the encounter with police, have you in a courtroom where a minimal sentence and early release will have your thieving ass back on the streets on no time.
 
Police could use some better training, no doubt. However, watching your partner murder a man in the street doesn't require a law degree to know that's not right. That's not a lack of knowledge problem, it's a lack of discipline problem. A lack of accountability problem. A lack of leadership problem.
Go out to violent situations unarmed while training? Nope. Not going into that without the ability to defend myself. Better and more extensive training at the academy, better leadership, more accountability is the answer.
Pysch exams before, during and after? Yep, for sure.
Better pay? Absolutely, but that is no guarantee either. Again, more accountability and kill the we got each others back no matter what philosophy. You break the law, we as a unit throw your ass out.
As a helpful tip for would be hoodlums. Try not breaking the law for awhile. Should you choose to break the law and have the misfortune of getting caught, try not running your fuckin mouth and just surrender without resistance. This alone will greatly improve your chances of surviving the encounter with police, have you in a courtroom where a minimal sentence and early release will have your thieving ass back on the streets on no time.
inb4 "the majority of cops are good apples" that just happen to tacitly condone cop on citizen violence by staying silent. We need whistleblower incentives like the IRS & FEC has.
 
Last edited:
inb4 "the majority of cops are good apples" that just happen to tacitly condone cop on citizen violence by staying silent.
Kinda, but I would say they accept it as part of the job rather than condone it. That is the result of poor leadership, zero accountability, and fear. The new guy on this most recent case says he was afraid to stop the more senior cop. There is no doubt he was told day one, hour one, minute one, we cover each other out there no matter what. We'll sort out the details later. You want to be the rat, the guy we can't count on? Then good luck when you find yourself in a pinch and need assistance. That is fear being instilled from the very first day, leadership knows and approves it. Until that is addressed all of the classroom training in the world won't help.
 
If this is what they mean by "defund" and "disband," then they should clarify (if they haven't already). The casual observer simply hears them demanding, "GET RID OF THE POLICE!"

Criminals smacking their lips, aren't they?
 
Back
Top