Obviously, the only way you could TELL in advance that anything is mispriced is if it's an arbritrage. What I mean when I say "you think that X is mispriced" is that one makes a prediction of some sort (relative value, absolute value etc) and makes a bet on this prediction being correct. If your prediction methodology is good, you will be correct more frequently in dollar-weighted terms.IMO you can't tell in advance if VOL is mis priced, same way you can't tell if the stock is going up or down... the move afterwards defines the correct vol...
As a propster, you are willing to pay vig to take advantage of informational asymmetry (in whatever form, be it statistical analysis, inside knowledge or synthetic understanding of expected supply and demand).
Yes. In some cases it's a combination of a few of these - e.g. if you have a good knowledge of the structured product issueance, it combines expectations of supply and demand with some insider knowledge (if you know that something is coming due or being issued).Would you say these are apt elaborations of your description of informational asymmetries?
I'll add one more thing.
Every monetary decision you'll ever make will be a tug of war between your goals, your emotions and the self-interest of any middle men involved. It is very useful to break down every situation using these three "principal components". It is definitely true in the context of proprietary trading, but just as true in car shopping, selling your home or buying a Gucci bag for your girlfriend.