Buttontrader

Quote from roberk:


How can the ticks be any different from any other broker or provider as IB gets its data direct from the exchange?
You can check against esignal for example and see that they update at the same time .:confused:
Has anyone compared Ninja trader with BT?
More...

Interesting questions. I am using NinjaTrader and I am guessing
it gets the same data as BT would, which is data from IB every
0.7 seconds. I would think the SuperDom as it is called in NT
would have different market depth figures if the data was tick by
tick instead of data that comes in every 0.7 seconds. But as you
know using these API's you get what IB gives you. Which is not
true tick by tick data. Perhaps if the data were tick by tick it would
change so quick you couldn't read the numbers... :p
 
Can I do a quick poll to find out "what" technical analysis software you guys are using along with ButtonTrader (BT)? I like BT's interface for Buying and Selling. However it's useless for determining when to place Buy or Sell. So obviously, unless you are clairvoyant, you are all using technical analysis in conjunction with BT.

So the poll is: "What software package(s) and Data Feed(s) are you using to support the use of ButtonTrader?"

Thanks
 
Quote from Wolf:



So the poll is: "What software package(s) and Data Feed(s) are you using to support the use of ButtonTrader?"

Thanks
More...

I believe you can only use ButtonTrader with Interactive Brokers
feed so if you want ButtonTrader to match your charts you could
use SierraCharts, QuoteTracker, TahoeCharts (which is just starting
out) and I believe EnsignSoftware. There are probably more than
this but I cannot remember them at the moment...
 
Quote from version77:

I believe you can only use ButtonTrader with Interactive Brokers
feed so if you want ButtonTrader to match your charts you could
use SierraCharts, QuoteTracker, TahoeCharts (which is just starting
out) and I believe EnsignSoftware. There are probably more than
this but I cannot remember them at the moment...
More...


This is what I'm trying to document in my FAQ. If you want ButtonTrader to match your charts you NEED TO USE: SierraCharts, QuoteTracker, TahoeCharts (and I believe) EnsignSoftware. This is because they all use the same Interactive Brokers data feed.

On the other hand you don't care if the charts match if you have a better/different data stream. Then any tick data in ButtonTrader becomes noise. This becomes the basis for using an integrated platform.

After reviewing ButtonTrader I'd suggest they completely lose the data tracking because it is only noise. You have to use a separate T/A package anyway. A ButtonTrader API would be great because I love the trade management interface. I'd like to integrate ButtonTrader and manage it from my DotNet app rather than use the "fingers and eyeballs" approach.

Note: I'm up to 40 different trading platforms and 3 different API's in my FAQ. The most heavily used is IB's API. It would be great if anyone could Post or IM me any of current platforms that used IB and any add-on platform relationships. Next up: WealthLab...
 
When they hook up to Jtrader you can compare...it is hard to see the difference by eye...but in a fast moving market, perhaps it makes a difference to a true scalper(1-3 ticks), but what do I know? Reading about the order book maniplation ....they are one step ahead of the retail trader...

Michael B.

P.S. to be retail and to truly scalp, would require actually to fade what you see...how else could you compete, without anticipating?...


Quote from version77:

Interesting questions. I am using NinjaTrader and I am guessing
it gets the same data as BT would, which is data from IB every
0.7 seconds. I would think the SuperDom as it is called in NT
would have different market depth figures if the data was tick by
tick instead of data that comes in every 0.7 seconds. But as you
know using these API's you get what IB gives you. Which is not
true tick by tick data. Perhaps if the data were tick by tick it would
change so quick you couldn't read the numbers... :p
More...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top