Quote from clacy:
Yes, as you say, any tax increases will not be to pay down our debt, but rather the Dems in charge will look at it as an opportunity to spend even more.
Prove to me first that you can dramatically cut spending, and then I'll lead the effort for a temporary tax increase to get us out of debt.
That first thing will never happen though....
I think, unfortunately, we're in such a hole now that normal fiscal measures such as dropping taxes and cutting spending won't help us anymore.
Our problem is that we are painted into a corner. Wall Street has forced companies to export all our manufacturing jobs to China, so that the regular person no longer makes their money from making stuff, but from selling stuff, and generally selling to Americans. If we actually made things, we could drop the value of the dollar and start selling to other countries and export our way out of this problem. But since we don't do that anymore, there's NO WAY for us to generate money.
If people stop spending, like they've done in the past 1.5 years, then all those jobs associated with buying and selling between Americans are fucked.
Normally, when you get into a financial mess, you stop spending and try to increase your income. Well, the government can't stop spending at this point, because they're the only ones generating any income in the economy, and if they stop spending, then even more jobs will be lost. So they're forced to spend.
Likewise, because so much jobs are lost and because housing has lost so much value, everyone feels poor, so they stopped spending. Remember, 70% of our economy is services based, meaning that we are buying and selling amongst ourselves. The only way to recover our economy is by stimulating spending by us Americans.
There are 2 ways out of this mess to get people to start spending again:
1) increase the value of the houses. This is what Bernanke has been trying to do by buying up MBSs. By forcing low interest rates, he hoped to stimulate house buying so that house prices hit a floor and start going up, and so that Americans to stop feeling "poor" so that they will spend more of their money. But that is essentially failed. Case-Shiller shows home prices dropping by 2% in the 4th quarter. This is because of lack of jobs.
2) increase jobs. Once people start getting more jobs, they will start spending again, and they will buy houses, etc. But the so-called stimulus by Obama last year has only lost us millions of jobs. Good job.
(Last year, I would have included increase the stock market because 401ks got decimated and that also made people feel poor, but Obama and the PPT team did a good job of juicing the markets last year so that most of the retirees were in decent shape as long as they didn't change anything.)
So now this is the hole we're in. We need to either increase housing or increase jobs. To increase housing Bernanke has the nuclear option which is to inflate everything by printing more money, so that everyone gets out of debt. This is somewhat unlikely, but it's still on the table. If he does this, we all might as well leave the US because the US dollar will become the US peso, it will lose reserve status, and everything will lose value relative to the world, and things we import will become very expensive (like gas). However, Americans (with fixed rate loans) will become out of debt, which would eventually lead to a recovering economy.
The other way is to increase taxes. As I've mentioned, if consumers won't spend, then the government will squeeze the money out of the ones who still have jobs and then spend it in hopes that it will stimulate jobs. Will this work? I dunno, we've never been in this situation before.
But to me, logically, it's the only thing they can do now, unless there is a immaculate miraculous recovery in consumer spending.