I see you post good things, but I don't agree with this one. It all depends on how he plans to trade options. If we are talking SPY options, and only buying them, the risk is quite limited. If the ES has a range of 10 points for the day, then many options that are ATM would move about what, 50 cents, or a bit more? If all he was going to do was to day trade these options, he could comfortably risk $20 on each trade and follow the movement of the S&P's quite nicely. The $20 risk would also work out to be 2% of his account. Some say to not risk more than 1%, but alas, its a small account, so 2% is acceptable. After 20 trades, he may very well be up 10% or 20%, or down this same amount, but nevertheless, he will have a result, trading real money, with real emotions on the line, or lack thereof.
Sure the commissions will hugely kill his profitability, and slippage may be a problem, but once again, on a SPY option, that slippage will be 1 or 2 cents, hence only $1 or $2. Is it really better to have a 10k account and be risking a full $12.50 per tick on ES vs. $1 per tick on SPY options? If he is gonna blow out, might as well do this with a 1k account vs. a 10k account. Options will I think allow for experience will limited risk if all he is doing is buying calls and puts. All trades either work or they don't, and if he focuses on firm rules of risk and rewards and sticks to this, he will wins some trades, lose some trades, and perhaps even be ahead in the long run.