Bright Vs Echo
- Thread starter hotlanta
- Start date
I hate mud-chucking as much as the next guy, but please remember 3 things when you're slapping wrists over "personal attacks":
(1) Your standards must apply to everyone--EVEN THE SPONSORS OF THIS BOARD
(2) You should take the time to read the posts of the members who provoke the "personal attacks" before you jump the gun. A little research quite often uncovers the suspect and antagonistic nature of many prominent members posts on this board.
(3) Not all "personal attacks" are without merit. The slope is slipery when you start censoring to save someone's reputation or edit someone's "tone."
If you want to turn this into a church chat or sponsor-protected venue then that's your choice. But the free rebuttals of individuals who aren't afraid to challenge the institutions of this board are the best checks and balances system I know of, and the only reason many people tune in to this station.
(1) Your standards must apply to everyone--EVEN THE SPONSORS OF THIS BOARD
(2) You should take the time to read the posts of the members who provoke the "personal attacks" before you jump the gun. A little research quite often uncovers the suspect and antagonistic nature of many prominent members posts on this board.
(3) Not all "personal attacks" are without merit. The slope is slipery when you start censoring to save someone's reputation or edit someone's "tone."
If you want to turn this into a church chat or sponsor-protected venue then that's your choice. But the free rebuttals of individuals who aren't afraid to challenge the institutions of this board are the best checks and balances system I know of, and the only reason many people tune in to this station.
Magna
Administrator
InyOutty,
As your note was posted here, and I am the moderator of the Professional Firms forum, I'll take this opportunity to address your concerns.
As your note was posted here, and I am the moderator of the Professional Firms forum, I'll take this opportunity to address your concerns.
Absolutely, but to be truthful I have yet to see representatives of EchoTrade, Bright Trading, Leiber & Weissman, TerranovaOnline, Interactive Brokers, etc. stoop to personal attacks. Sure, they get frustrated when the same questions are asked over and over, also when they are the recipients of mud-slinging, but I don't see them telling people to "grow up", or calling people "idiots", etc. If that were to happen on this forum, I would apply the same standards to them.
I may disagree with certain sponsors relentless marketing, etc. but they pay for that privilege and if it bothers you please tune it out as best you can. And I rarely see anything that passes for their so-called antagonistic nature....unless failing to answer a question, or answering a question in a manner that is unacceptable to the questioner can be considered antagonistic. Again, I read ALL posts on this forum.
I am not editing or censoring to save someone's "reputation". But I disagree with you regarding personal attacks; on this forum they are all without merit. And that also goes for commentary from members directed at other members, not just at sponsors.
I welcome the rebuttal of individuals and the challenging of institutions. And I agree, that provides an excellent checks 'n balances to individual and corporate excess. But that does not require personal attacks, and that is the sole issue I was addressing.
I would like to know how someone goes about getting in touch with Echo. I have emailed twice and left a message on Jeff Dewitts answering machine both several days ago to no avail. I emailed Don and got a response within the day. Doesn't leave me with many options, just wondering if anyone else gets the same treatment from Echo.
Bryan Roberts
Guest
check ur mailbox!!!!