Quote from tradingjournals:
You nailed it with your scenario. I doubt they will answer . Maybe the 5K account would not be allowed until your other account has generated profits that might cover the total of $5K. I would also bet that if they see something not going as they judge, they step in and cancel/freeze the account. If you do not trade the 20K account, they can still make money if your capital is used in other trades. With a SPAN margin the 3% interest on cash they earn can generate 50% a year, which is $10K on a $20K account.
Here is another point. My alluding to the second account in the posts,people may call and dream of it as the end product/service. So they get more leads.
Quote from tradingjournals:
To pick their mind for free? You are not offering a job, and yet you want them to tell you what they know.
Quote from Shreddog:
Some problems with your analysis:
1) His commission has not changed with the 80/20 payout change. You pay the same at the new 80% payout as you did at 100%. There's no "choice" - you either take 80/20 at the old commission rate or leave it.
2) Don's rates are .005 for the first 1000, .003 for the rest on any given ticket. A lot of high volume automated traders don't trade more than 1000 shrs/order and therefore would be paying .005 all the time.
Regardless, high volume traders can get better rates and keep 100% of the profits retail as Don has already conceded.
Quote from Robert A. Green:
On our blog and podcast this week, I discussed Goldman's reaction to Fin Reg and FINRA regulatory notice 10-18 calling for their prop trading firm customers to pay out prop traders 80% or less. I can't post links, so see our site.
This podcast is mostly on forex changes in Fin Reg. I will join this thread with other comments next week._
Quote from Maverick74:
Does it matter? GS determined the number. How does GS determine how much they want to ass rape their clients on OTC transactions? Maybe they just pull the number out of a hat every time a client calls for a quote on a 5 year 6% floating rate Brazilian bond denominated in Euros that converts into a MBS when long term rates hit 7% or when it starts raining in Chile whichever comes first.

Quote from LEAPup:
Can you post a link to your site? I am wanting to know if the gearing on spot fx really is going to drop to 10:1 or not. Thanks!
Quote from Maverick74:
So I guess I found another angle here. According to this link, from the first 10k made, 2k goes to the software developers. Then another 50% goes to Bob. I don't see anything wrong with this per se. You basically are looking for a way to monetize your software and give a kickback to the developers. I suspect before you were giving them some kind of cut on the commissions but with rates having to be lowered you needed to find a new way to pay them. Hence the JVC program.
http://www.stocktrading.com/jvc.html
"When account reaches $10,000 positive, $2,000 will go to program developers, and the other will be split 50/50 between trader and Bob."