Bride of If You Can Draw A Straight Line

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here is what a beginner's chart of the first hour of the NQ open may look like using straight lines. I created this for any of the people currently following this method, but not having advanced to the level where most of the discussion is currently taking place in the Son thread.

I know that when DB did things like this when I was studying the basics, it was always very helpful for me. Open to questions / differences of opinion if anyone has any.
 

Attachments

II1Heroic,

Nice chart and comments. It would be nice to see the same chart annotated from the view of a more advanced trader if you have the time. Maybe for the Son thread?
 
Quote from bmwhendrix:

II1Heroic,

Nice chart and comments.


It would be nice to see the same chart annotated from the view of a more advanced trader if you have the time. Maybe for the Son thread?
More...


BMW,

With all due respect to you… doing so would be disrespectful to II1H

He’s found his way..., that is his chart - it stands on its own merit

====================

II1H,

Great job Sir


RN
 
I post this here -- from another site -- not because I'm mentioned but because I like the sentiments expressed regarding the path one chooses and the value that can be obtained from a trading forum (if one can shovel aside what can sometimes seem like insurmountable piles of drek):

  • If you accept that trading can't really be taught or handed over to someone via posts or words, and that the main features of successful trading have been disseminated over time by the market wizards and others. Then all that is left is for one to spend time on it themselves, develop their own understanding and carve out their own niche. If they already have carved it, then all that is left is to repeat truths that are known for a 100 years to the new generation, discuss any differences in the current cycle and shoot the breeze with others. Trading forums provide an option for this for both the newcomer and the experienced.

    So they provide an option for the successful to get rid of some of their boredom and feel like they are giving back, and for the newbies to get rid of some of their frustration at losing, and find comfort in the herd. That is why they work, in an industry where you would think a trading forum can't possibly work because it is all competitive and everybody's interest should be in others losing. Amazingly there are a few who do want to help. Is it down to some underlying guilt at knowing that they are taking the money of others on a daily or weekly basis?

    In these ways, trading forums all offer something 'useful'. Maybe not so useful in developing an edge, but useful for the psyche. Unfortunately, as with nature, parasites develop, who see the whole thing as prey of which they can suck blood from. They may be your common garden vendor or may be even the site owners and admin. These become an irritant to the other species, but if nature finds mosquitos and leeches necessary, then they must be needed in the system somehow. Perhaps someone can enlighten us as to why they are necessary.

    The worst site for this parasitic infestation seems to be ***** ******* (and I don't think that's the one you are referring to as the zoo). ***** was vouched for by all the gurus over there. ******* vouched for him too, and is also vouched for by dozens of others there, but he probably can't trade either, and was outed by one of his own members (although the cover-up was quick). There are at least half a dozen off shoots of ******* and I'm sure the list could go on. ****** seemed to disappear prior to all the scandal. Seems like these people are working together.

    From what I've seen, there are lots of gurus and vendors with cherry picked charts on all of these sites. Very few have held up to my own testing - that is testing whether what they say is true and whether they can speak clearly rather than talk in generalities.

    DBPhoenix was one of those from here that did stand up to testing. There are two or three other posters here that also have stood up to testing.

    Here is something for the new trader: If you can't find an edge, don't worry too much, unleveraged buy and hold for indices or a basket of well chosen stocks is profitable if you can afford to wait. Add a bit of timing to it, and you've got something good. Of course there are better ways to trade, but if one is stuck in the myth that nothing works, and hasn't found anything good yet, well there you go.

    Seeker


If one hangs around long enough, eventually those who claim to be expert traders will say something that suggests that they are not expert at all, or even trade. This something may have to do with indicators, or trendlines, or "randomness", or mean reversion. One may even discover that a respected member who has been around for years has never gone beyond paper trading.

Therefore it behooves the beginner to ignore -- as soon as and as quickly as possible -- most if not all what is posted on message boards and rely on the only entity that matters: the market itself.

As Gringo posted in another thread:

  • The author [Wm O'Neil] of the book, How to Make Money in Stocks, gives an example of a Harvard professor, who asked his class to submit and assignment about fish. He failed them all because they used all kinds of resources to gather information , but none of them bothered to gather direct evidence. "If you want to know about the fish" said the professor, "then observe the fish swim." (Quotes here are probably not exact as it's been a long time since I read that book)

    The same applies to trading. All your gains and losses are dependent on one thing and one thing only. And that thing is price. Your gains and losses are not depended on what the president said or did, but what the price did. Yes, everything is inter-linked but the price will determine whether you're profitable or not. Highly obtuse philosophical erudition isn't going to make it simple for you to comprehend, let alone translate to a profitable trading plan.

    You need to observe price yourself and come to your own conclusions. This literally means start looking at price and how it behaves, and how it it turns and all the variations in between. Those with no prior knowledge have an extremely high chance of getting it figured out quickly if they don't get lost.

    It is up to you to decide what kind of a trader you wish to become. You need to first find out how to do it, and then how to find an edge.

    All we can offer is advice, of which some you'll comprehend, and some you won't. In time the veil can part, but it will require focus, dedication and discipline. You are young, ambitious, and aware of what you want. You already have a slight edge. However, there are no guarantees in this business. [The] Majority fail.


Finally, a note about what one sees, or thinks he sees, in charts, much less the conclusions he draws from these "observations":

  • Put simply, support is the price at which those who have enough money to make a difference are willing to show their support by retarding, halting, and reversing the decline by buying. Resistance is the price at which those who have enough money to make a difference attempt to retard, halt, and reverse a rise by selling. Whether one calls this money professional or big or smart or institutional or crooked or manipulative or (fill in the blank) is irrelevant. If repeated attempts to sell below this support level are met by buying which is sufficient to turn price back, these little reversals will eventually form a line, or zone. Ditto with resistance.

    A swing high or low represents a point at which traders are no longer able to find trades. Whether that point represents important support or resistance will be seen the next time traders push price in that direction. But everyone knows this point, even if they aren't following a chart. It exists independently of the trader and his lines and charts and indicators and displays. It is the point beyond which price could not go. Hence its importance, both to those who want to see price move higher and those who don't.

    Therefore, before coming to any conclusions about what “works” or “doesn’t work”, and thus does or does not provide an edge, one ought to keep in mind that a given event -- such as price seemingly finding support or resistance at a trendline (or moving average, candlestick, Pivot Point, Fib level or whatever) -- may be only incidental to what is truly providing that support or resistance.

    A fundamental misunderstanding of how "indicators" are calculated and what they're supposed to do can lead to all sorts of off-task behavior. We think we see the indicators indicating something, or not, and believe we have made an important discovery. We then devote our efforts to improving the hit rate and the probability of whatever it is we think the indicator is indicating when our efforts ought to be focused on determining whether or not the indicator is actually indicating what we think it's indicating. In most if not all cases, it isn't.

    Consider the virgin being tossed into the volcano: sometimes it results in a great crop, sometimes it doesn't. Maybe tossing her in earlier or later will change the probability of a healthy crop. Maybe two virgins are better than one. Maybe six. Maybe tall virgins are more effective than short ones. And surely age is important. But does the robustness of the crop really have anything to do with tossing the virgin into the volcano in the first place?

    The money under the pillow is not evidence of the existence of the tooth fairy, and spring will arrive regardless of whether the virgin is tossed into the volcano or not.
 
Quote from llIHeroic:

Here is what a beginner's chart of the first hour of the NQ open may look like using straight lines. I created this for any of the people currently following this method, but not having advanced to the level where most of the discussion is currently taking place in the Son thread.

I know that when DB did things like this when I was studying the basics, it was always very helpful for me. Open to questions / differences of opinion if anyone has any.
More...

Hero,

Great post!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top