Quote from LondonUSTrader:
Making predictions although a bit of harmless fun is a fool's game. If you make enough calls sooner or later you might get one right. But one call in isolation from one's trackrecord is meaningless.
Just trade the action. Forget about predicting where the market will go.
Quote from hank rollins:
totally untrue and inappropriate nonsense from a moderator no less. why a moderator would attempt to squelch the very thing that makes a message board work, i have no clue.
i have made very very few big calls over my 5 year historic posting record. i trade systematically and the posts are basically public notes to myself
good bye for now, ET.
Actually, I side with LondonUSTrader on this one. Further, you don't necessarily have to short the lows if you are "trading the action." The "action" can include volume and breadth which, together with price, can paint a different picture than what price alone would suggest. But I am intrigued by your comment on sentiment. How do you gauge sentiment, if I may ask?Quote from Cutten:
Sometimes the price-action in isolation is deceptive. Friday and Monday Globex is a great example - very bearish action, but it should have been bought, not shorted. Someone trading the action would have been shorting the lows on Monday. The thing you are missing is sentiment. When price action is bearish, but sentiment is also very bearish, then usually this is a time to buy, not short. Or at least, go flat or buy calls until short-term momentum turns up. The time to short is where price action is bearish, but sentiment is neutral or, even better, bullish/in denial.
Quote from Cutten:
Even though Hank Rollins (great nickname btw!) was wrong on this call, I agree with him. Every trader ends up with egg on his face, usually at least once or twice a year. It's nothing to be ashamed of. I'd rather have someone who makes calls and gets some right, some wrong, than someone who makes no calls and snipes after the fact. I've made a few calls here on ET, some have worked very well, some have not worked, but the only way to judge them is by how much you lost if they were wrong vs how much they made if you were right. Hank will not lose his shirt on this call (especially with a 150 point stop on the Dow), he will just give back some open profits. But he has made decent calls on oil twice from the short side recently. I bet he made more on the 2 oil shorts than he even has given back in profits on this one so far.
A famous trader once said it is not how often you are right that matters, but how much you make when you are right, versus how much you lose when you are wrong. That is the real essence of trading.

Quote from EqtTrdr:
new pope rally is so free $$$