In a way, Schiff is a bit blind to the whole game that is the market. Its DNA is to camouflage its true performance character over time. So that this happens in all of finance is really no surprise.
Think about the way that indeces work. Take the DOW for example. It used to be composed to companies that are now bankrupt or nearly worthless. What replaces them? Stocks like Apple. So, the one goal of markets is not to reflect true value over time and to keep score of wins and loses. In fact, it is exactly the opposite. To hide losers from the index, and to continue to supply it with winners.If you replace "stocks" with "interest rates" and "indeces" with the "FED", it is the same game of obfuscation with different names to stand in. The whole idea is to keep the illusion going as long as possible. And since human beings have a very poor understanding of longer time periods, they will believe just about anything over the short term, say on the order of a quarter of their lifetimes. The market needs a constant supply of inexperienced young people to continue to fuel The Matrix. Except this matrix turns people not into a battery, but into an investor full of hope.
So, the market as a reflection of accumulated wealth over time is a myth, and therefore a terrible measure or economic well being. It all depends on what your starting point and ending point of investment is/was, and whether you were lucky enough to be in the right place at the right time.
Where are all the people's yatch? Or should I be more humble and just hope for: where is the American Dream?