Bhel puri...Improving Brooks the Padu Way

a journal is to record my trades...not to help others...they are beyond help and i have to answer a thousand questions if i suggest something

and i post when i have time

once i log in to my trade account i log out of ET.......i do not want to be thinking of anything but trading
I am just trying to understand why you started this journal for?

You said you are improving Brooks. Where is your track record to show you are winning or losing in the improvement process?

Sorry, just trying to understand why you even waste time posting in this journal.

Only building a track record like this can help you https://kinfo.com/leaderboard/profit

NOTHING else on earth. Please delete this journal and start a new journal stating a location where viewers can view your actual live 3rd party audit track record of real time money trades.

If you can not do this, then please study perfecting your trading skills until you can. Otherwise people are going to pick on you sir and give you headache.
 
Last edited:
all i do is i see what the market is doing and assume it will do the same thing which it usually does.....

if it does something slightly or totally different then i know that will continue.

this is what Brooks suggests but he also suggests a thousand other things which did not work for me.

this is working so as long as it lasts ......
 
if you remember i usd to post all my trades live......that was when i found that ET has 95% only trolls.
so why should i make the effort to show my trades or post anything sensible here.
 
all brooks talks about is breakouts pull backs....all stuff talked about for a hundred years and still useful...

he does not claim to know anything new or earth shattering.

so how can he be frauding anyone.

he is asking a fee for his efforts which the student agrees to pay....so what is wrong with something mutually agreed by two persons.

if what he teaches does not work then it is technical analysis that does not work
 
FALSE!

The only reasons to post a journal on a public forum like this are the following...

1. You wish to brag and attempt to suck people into a scheme that you are formulating.

2. To simply show what you are doing and are doing so with no ulterior motive. You are just being generous with your time, and are attempting to help others generate trading ideas based upon your own examples of the trades you have made.

3. To simply show what you are doing with your trading, to request feedback from other traders who may help you along your journey if ye be struggling.

If you wish to record your trades, it does not have to be done on a public forum. You can do that yourself.

Posting your trade journal on a public forum is serving a purpose you think will impact the public, i.e. OTHER PEOPLE.

Flom.

I agree.

And for whatever reason one wants to have a public journal, it is worthless if there is no end off day balance posted every single trading day.

Everyone can have a few successful trades here and there and post these online, but that doesn't mean the trader is actually profitable, he/she can be hiding tons of losing trades that no one knows about.
 
if you remember i usd to post all my trades live......that was when i found that ET has 95% only trolls.
so why should i make the effort to show my trades or post anything sensible here.

Isn't it funny that only your thread gets trolled like this? I don't see any other trading journals here getting trolled like this.

Maybe you are part of the issue ...

There are plenty of examples. You have gotten some good advise in your previous threads, about discipline and money management and stuff like that, but you always said you didn't need any of that, you knew it all, you were the best trader ever, blablabla, while doing nothing but blowing your accounts. And now all of a sudden you realised you actually do need discipline that to E2T?

A few good trading day's don't actually mean you turned profitable. I am afraid your cockiness will catch up with you again if you are not careful.
 
Back
Top