Quote from bro59:
I second what lorax has to say above.
In the last few months I've found that coin stores are willing to pay a premium to spot for rounds and small bars, just ask around. Remember that with Craigslist there are issues with trust and shipping, and with Ebay there are the fees which can be almost 10% if you also use PayPal.
Do a little shopping around and don't accept a large discount to spot.