Quote from marketsurfer:
Victor Niederhoffer is definitely in the top 5 of all time. Despite the blow ups, this guy came from absolutely nothing built hugely succesful trading businesses then he was knocked back down, came back in a heroic way, then was knocked down again--potentially by his own demons this time---i don't think anyone in market history was knocked down to that extent than came back to top rankings other then VN. In addition, the monsters of the financial world who have emerged from his tutelege is a truly surprising list of a dozen plus 100 millionaires and near billionaires. i wouldn't be surprised to see comeback #3 from this true trader/educator.
surf
I haven't post for years but I feel this overwhelming urge to respond to MarketSurfer 's ludicrous assetsion that victor is a top trader, you are almost redefining the term, I just can't believe you said that, how bias can u get?
you acknowledge he blew up two times and yet you still consider him a top trader, do u know what define of a top trader? He may be a top writer (his books are very good), a good educator and a good come-backer...but definitely not a top trader...
a good, not even top, trader never blows up... top risk management and iron clad discipline is what defines a good trader.
Not to mention being objective and open-minded, victor can never be a good trader because he is too arrogant (he really enjoys mental masturbation, read his books), emotional (you can see it in his desciption of trading) and never admits his errors( he justifies his blow-ups), which is why he makes again and again.
You two have been bashing trend-followers since forever and those guys are making 50% in 2008 and manages billions more than Victor. When the facts change, change your mind, wake up..man..
Ever wonder why you are still here on the forum after all these years and never made it? It's the same reason you believe Victor is a good trader, the same reason you believe trend-following doesn't work, you are simply detached from reality...but the markets needs people like you, they can't funcion without losers...