Quote from Catalite:
I don't see the benefit of a long-term short in stocks. Maybe you can make 100% over a long time period on a couple of stocks, but most don't go down that far. In a rising market it makes sense to be long, with a few hedges if you are really risk averse. A short will never triple in value. The short-trading strategies I've seen only work in downward trending markets. And they are TRADING strategies, not short-and- forget strategies. Most take profits in the 30-35% area and then look for another entry in a counter-trend rally.
From a market timing standpoint, it is extremely unlikely to have a significant (over 30%) decline in the stock market within four years of a crash (ie. 2008 decline).
I have had this debate a lot. If your not using capital directly. (Ie shorting) how does one calculate rate of return? The collateral was theoretically already being used and invested so cost of capital is dividends and interest?
The risk side however isn't clear either. What's your risk? Ie worst case scenario? Buyout tomorrow? Up 100%? I would argue that the risk is very similar to being long.... Not the same but similar....