Best Country for Trading (Tax efficiency)

Quote from luisHK:

Also about Singapore - a place I like, and the asian state offering closest living standards to european's IME (possibly besides Japan but I haven't spent time there for a while, and as a foreigner you will be more at a handicap than in Singapore) - I didn't check closely recently but the real estate wasn't as expensive as HK, Paris, London or even less Monaco. In Sentosa Cove, which is quite high end for Singapore, you could get 100sqm+ apartment for 1million USD and fancy villas for 3 to 7million - forget about that in Paris, Monaco or London - last time I was in Monaco agencies were asking 50000 EUROS up for nothing special small apartments in not particulary prestigious areas. 100k up per sqm doesn't seem exceptional.

London isn't as pricey as it seems, if you are flexible. For example, for 1 million US you can get a modern 100sqm apartment in places in zone 1 or 2 in London e.g. Clerkenwell, Camden, Islington, Fulham etc. These are walkable to the centre or have quick public transport, are pretty safe, have plenty of decent bars, restaurants and clubs etc.

My views on space - single person only needs 50-60sqm, and 70-80 is a luxurious amount of space. Cohabiting couple need 70-80, and 90-100 is luxurious. Since property is so expensive, it is better to keep space as small as you can handle. Most people get too much space, then don't use it - they just fill it with clutter. I found that living alone even in an 80 sqm 2-bedroom apartment, I rarely used the 2nd bedroom. I once lived in a 90sqm house and 2 of the rooms I hardly ever used. Bedroom, living room, kitchen, bathroom is all you need for 1 person - get a spacious living room and put a corner desk and a laptop in the corner, and you have a home office too.

Finally, as an expat trader/investor I would always rent rather than buy. Transactions costs for property are huge, as an expat you are far less tied to one place, you have foreign exchange risk, and mortgage finance is more difficult to find and more expensive. Finally, in international centres, renting is usually very cheap compared to owning.
 
Quote from softdown:

Great advice. You seem to have put a lot of thought into these matters.
Are you an expat ? If so, where do you currently live ?

Yes, I have spent 2 years living outside my home country, in a couple of places in Europe. I won't say where, for privacy reasons. Anyway, due to the disadvantages I found, I will probably return to my home country in a few months. I don't regret my expat experience but just want to give a more realistic picture of the downsides, since the upsides are known to most.
 
Quote from npnotesin:

Costa Rica, Chile and Uruguay don't tax foreign income of non-residents.
If you are a U.S. citizen you will pay U.S. taxes regardless of where you live, however you may get some credit for foreign taxes paid, but if you don't pay foreign taxes, you'll obviously not be eligible for any credit toward your U.S. taxes. Time to emigrate? The IRS never sleeps!
 
Quote from Maverick2608:

"Dear Inland Revenue,

I understand that non-domiciled foreign holders of a permanent residency permit in Malta are taxable on a remittance basis only.

Question: Is trading income from trading US equities through a US broker considered foreign-sourced income?

Qualifications:
The exchanges, the securities, the broker and the gains are located abroad
The person doing the trading is located in Malta

Your help is greatly appreciated.

Thank you."

I received the following reply:

"Dear Sir,

Any trading income that is made while one is residing physically in Malta is considered as income arising in Malta and taxable in Malta."

Consequently, I consider the simple setup in Malta as dead.

Dozens of advisors in Malta promote a corporate setup consisting of two Maltese trading companies coupled with an offshore (Belize) mother company which should result in an effective tax rate of 5-8%.

I may forward a question to the Inland Revenue Department to confirm whether this setup is indeed legal.

However, I prefer a simple setup in order to lower the risk of getting caught by legal fine print/details and to avoid too much dependence on legal advisors.

For that reason at the moment I prefer Andorra or Dubai as these locations involve no income tax and thus present a clean and simple setup.

(I am a Scandinavian citizen. I realize that this does not apply to US citizens as I understand you are taxed on a global basis irrepective of where you reside.)

what i remember capital gains are tax free in Malta. But maby that has changed.
if you like to reside in Malta, why not open a professional investment fund in Gibraltar/ireland or offshore, which doesnt cost you much, trade the fund as the fund manager and pay you the capital gains as fund quotes...
 
Quote from Mvector:

I would non-file if I lived in a foreign country and made income in the foreign country - no way would I file a return or pay taxes to irs regardless of the current laws. 35 million us citizens were non-filers last year and less than .001% have been audited. The amount of non-filers is growing rapidly past 10 years.

Remember in today's electronic age, records last forever and are widely shared, more so as the years pass by. You will be vulnerable to being caught for the rest of your life. You will lose piece of mind and always be worrying about it at some level. Did you read about those Swiss bank accounts that an employee handed over to foreign tax authorities?

Also, it's not just tax authorities you have to worry about. If someone else finds out, they gain the power to put you in jail for many years and to ruin your reputation and finances. That makes you incredibly vulnerable to blackmail or extortion, and there are many people in the world, especially outside the 1st world, who won't hesitate to exploit that. All it takes is one corrupt brokerage or accountancy firm employee, or a bit of drunken loose talk in the local expat watering hole, and you could get into deep trouble. Think very carefully before breaking the law in a serious way.
 
Quote from piezoe:

If you are a U.S. citizen you will pay U.S. taxes regardless of where you live, however you may get some credit for foreign taxes paid, but if you don't pay foreign taxes, you'll obviously not be eligible for any credit toward your U.S. taxes. Time to emigrate? The IRS never sleeps!

That sounds very strange, are you 100% confident about that?

I live in Denmark and we've very tight tax regulations and laws, but still we're able to travel to another country, there is a lot of rules regarding that, but in short if you don't stay for more than 180 days each year in Denmark, don't own any property and have an address in a foreign country you are not subject for taxation i Denmark anymore.
 
The US taxes its citizens income no matter where it is earned. Although there are some offsets possible on salary the reality is that in terms of income earned abroad the US tax code is as unreasonable as it gets.

Or to put it directly -- it sucks.

Quote from januson:

That sounds very strange, are you 100% confident about that?

I live in Denmark and we've very tight tax regulations and laws, but still we're able to travel to another country, there is a lot of rules regarding that, but in short if you don't stay for more than 180 days each year in Denmark, don't own any property and have an address in a foreign country you are not subject for taxation i Denmark anymore.
 
Hi,

Here is another option that has not been discussed yet.

Im a european citizen and I have been changing countries regularly during the last two year. (I don't stay anywhere for more than 6 month)

I currently still hold residency in my home country and pay tax there.
Since I would like to continue my lifestyle as I do now, I thought it would be easiest to resign my residency and to live without being registered anywhere until I finally settle somewhere.

Is there something that prohibits me from not having residency anywhere?
This seems to be the easiest way to avoid tax if you don't mind to change places regularly. (Of course this is no long term solution, but it fits well for me as a mid 20s single with no kids)

I am aware that I will not be able to register a car and of similar problems without a registered address. However, I use my parents address for mail and they forward it.

kind regards, Chris
 
Quote from symbian11:

Hi,

Here is another option that has not been discussed yet.

Im a european citizen and I have been changing countries regularly during the last two year. (I don't stay anywhere for more than 6 month)

I currently still hold residency in my home country and pay tax there.
Since I would like to continue my lifestyle as I do now, I thought it would be easiest to resign my residency and to live without being registered anywhere until I finally settle somewhere.

Is there something that prohibits me from not having residency anywhere?
This seems to be the easiest way to avoid tax if you don't mind to change places regularly. (Of course this is no long term solution, but it fits well for me as a mid 20s single with no kids)

I am aware that I will not be able to register a car and of similar problems without a registered address. However, I use my parents address for mail and they forward it.

kind regards, Chris

You might lose your passport
 
Quote from Daal:

You might lose your passport

How would I lose the passport? I have never heard that it is possible to lose your primary citizenship unvoluntarily.
 
Back
Top