I didn't like that they didn't offer a cap on commish. Echo caps at 25 a ticket, and I do a lot of 3-5k trades, so it would cost me more for those. Their rate per share was also a bit higher even though I do 2mil +/- a month (though the number seems to go up a few 100k each month). I think echo is giving me a better offer, but their guys who I talked to at hold were very nice as well.