Quote from Magna:
Here's a list of my all-time favorites....
Forever Changes (Love))
WOW....GREAT LIST!!!
(maybe because it is kind of similar to my own).
I never would have thought there would be a single person here that would have known "Forever Changes". Great album. I still have the LP. (but no needle in my turntable...I really should do something about that). Truly one of the best albums, and worthy of a much shorter list.
Arthur Lee. "orange skies, carnivals and cotton candy...." Man...sometimes that tune just pops into my head still. And there is no way I have heard it in at least 20 years. (That's how long I've had a broken needle). Never ever heard it on the radio. Tomorrow I buy the CD!!
Only group of that era that to my knowledge did not tour. I practically lived at the Fillmore East. I can't think of another group that wasn't there. (Velvet Underground maybe...but I saw them somewhere in NY).
So Magna, in homage to your great list, I will add the Mothers of Invention's amazing "We're Only In It For The Money" to my list. For a few reasons. Great album on it's own merit. And the ingenious spoof cover (of Sgt. Pepper). And they just deserve to be on the list. And, Magna is a big fan!!
Now, only one question: Although you explained your criteria for your list, and it makes sense, how can you say, without some kind of disclaimer, that only the first album by Led Zeplin belongs on the list.
If there was a separate list of greatest debut albums of all times (Rock n Roll), then obviously Led Zeplin's first album would have to be the entire list.
But is it better on a general list than any number of LZ albums? (I had a similar dilemma with the Cream albums).
Oh, and a glaring ommision from my list (also to make Bung happy)..."Aladin Sane": David Bowie
And, how did any of us forget: "Desperado"?
Peace, Love, and Rock 'n Roll,

RS