Quote from Rearden Metal:
Even if there was just one single universal religion, and therefore zero chance of mistakenly picking the 'wrong' faith... This entire concept is STILL hopelessly flawed.
Let's say the one universally agreed upon religion was Catholicism, for example. Since when does 'belief' alone sufficiently meet all your religious requirements? What about all those pesky obligations and restrictions one must follow in order to earn a blissful afterlife? Confining one's self to nothing but marital sex (and no masturbation either)- that alone is a massive burden to bear! Add in all the other shit like Lent & having to attend mass regularly, and there's just <b>no way</b> you can claim that <i>"if you have belief or no belief, and there is no God, your outcomes are the same."</i> One dude got to enjoy hot young sluts all his life, while the other was stuck with blue balls and a Bible.
And that's just if the universal religion was (relatively mild) Catholicism. Switch that to Judaism or Islam, and your list of restrictions & obligations becomes an even lousier buzz kill.
Jesus Saves... but Moses Invests!
Interesting take. Your point in general is well taken - but it ironically also illustrates what many consider the point of Jesus' message. He was telling the pharisees that their man made law is bullshit and standing between the people (Israel) and God. Martin Luther and the reformation were telling the Catholic Church that the Churches made made shit like indulgences were worthless.
Protestants love to preach about Abraham being justified by his actions.
Obviously it is not a good "work" to attempt to kill your son on a hill. But it was because Abraham (the father of his people -to whom the promises were given) had faith in God's word or his promise that Abraham was found righteous. He was found righteous because he was willing to act in accord with Gods promise.
Abraham knew that God keeps his promises so there was no way God was going let him kill his first son. That was not a sacrifice that father had to make for the sake of his people.
Rules made by man do seem stupid. And its possible if you had a relationship with God he would not mind if you did blow with hookers on the hood of your car. That would be between you and God. IMHO. However God might have another plan. He might hook you up with the hottest piece of ass on the east coast who understands the only way to keep a guy truly satisfied is to make sure he walks out the door sated.
] whatever comes up in front of your face. This washes the guilt complex out of your subconscious mind and gradually clears your mind to make meaningful choices regarding the rest of your salvation.