Definitely VOD, using this method. This is not the FOTM/Index/1.3 sigma method of doing these things. This thread would have been a lot more interesting, had you gone down that route.
If you have an IC formed tightly around the money - on both the put and call side, on a volatile underlying... one of them is guaranteed to blow up, wiping out the position. At nearly 50:50 odds, at the money... heads you lose, tails you lose. Even if the r:r is 1:1.
"I want the risk reward 5:1, or less" ... what about the probability? Need to go further OTM to better the odds... something you are not doing, not really proving anything. I can risk $1 in a lottery for a reward of $1 million⦠seems safe, great risk reward!⦠but the odds arenât with you⦠at least play the odds better.