I can't pass judgement without having seen how his stuff worked.I take a slightly different approach. If I was a bloody beginner I would definitely appreciate critical voices who warn me about individuals whose only intent is to separate me from my money without me deriving any true benefit. That is the gratification I derive, which is to warn beginners that not all is as it seems. Showing only a few trades after the fact but hiding the others and then advertising oneself as a coach and teacher is dishonest in my book, and I won't debate all over why I think that is the case. My hope is that beginners are extra careful whom they choose to trust and pay for advice.
But someone new is gonna lose anyway (more than likely), so any help would probably be worthwhile I would think.
