Quote from hermit:
I am not talking about opinions here, I have seen number of traders posting on the PnL thread who have been profitable and posting blotters since a long time.
I dont believe that most profitable traders would be bothered/have time to talk about their trades/edges on a Journal unless they are working on some aspect of their trading and would require inputs or document the process.
You claimed to make an X amount and at the same time 'accused' others of 'bragging' making 'any' amount, all I am asking you is to prove your own claim first and if you don't then it leaves you in no position to play down others.
You are free to use indexing, astrology or random entries but this doesnt mean you have to insult what others chose to do and do well.