Astrology vs Stock Market Sentiments

Sentiment Spectrum said:
Want to know if anyone use astrology as one of trading tools.
From my humble experiences, astrology plays a key role driving stock market's underlying sentiments.
If interested, we can discuss and share our views on market sentiments and also market predictions as well.
More...
SS who is a 4 poster on ET (new to ET possibly) has opened a discussion.
Why not let the discussion roll on, I'm not a believer of predictions nor a believer in astrology, but I do like to hear people discuss issues outside of mainstreet thinking.
Shutting down an idea with stupid comments creates a reluctance which is counter productive.
 
themickey said:
It has long been recognized that moon cycle has a direct influence on tides and fishing.
Maybe not such an influence on deep water fish, more so on shallower water coastal fish.
The moon also has an influence on certain plants including plankton blooms.
The problem I see, is that trolls are not influenced by anything other than their own closed minds.
More...


Actually I think in truth it has long been recognised that astronomical occurrences coincide with stock price movements. But what I'd like to know before investing is "How?".
 
tomorton said:
Actually I think in truth it has long been recognised that astronomical occurrences coincide with stock price movements. But what I'd like to know before investing is "How?".
More...
I would not accept this. Reason...most, common , repetitive, orbital, future motion is known. Question is: has it been correctly discounted.
 
eurusdzn said:
I would not accept this. Reason...most, common , repetitive, orbital, future motion is known. Question is: has it been correctly discounted.
More...
Well I suppose it's like the old worn out TA argument.
The critics of TA say "prove it", (which some do) but also TA critics can't get it to work for them so they assume it is snake oil for everyone.
My observation on the subject of Astro and trading, those who are true believers are so secretive of their methods you would think they were Masonic Lodge members.
So no matter how far the discussion goes regarding Astro & trading, you will never learn anything because of this 'secretive' attitude they have.
Which brings on the next thought, anyone who is habitually super secretive may have something to hide - their failings.
So not wishing to torpedo this thread, I would love to hear an open discussion on it but I'm not holding my breath that this would ever happen.
 
themickey said:
My observation on the subject of Astro and trading, those who are true believers are so secretive of their methods you would think they were Masonic Lodge members.
More...

The non-exhaustive, uber-secretive, no google hits, fin-astro practitioners list, in no particular order.


WD Gann
George Bayer
Arch Crawford
Welles Wilder
Larry Pesavento
Ray Merriman
TS Philips
countless lesser knowns
 
Errr, WD Gann? Credibility?
Welles Wilder I think is also questionable.

As for the others I must confess my ignorance, dunno them and not gonna bother looking them up. Sorry.
 
 
Van_der_Voort_4 said:
On other forum i read some traders mention Arch Crawford and often talk about Bradley turn dates.It's closed forum only by invitation,found you some links from one of it's members blog.

http://thekeystonespeculator.blogspot.com/2018/01/spx-s-500-daily-chart-displays-bradley.html
http://thekeystonespeculator.blogspot.com/2016/02/bradley-turn-dates-2015-2016.html

https://bradleysiderograph.com/financial-astrology/arch-crawford/
More...
Yes, now this is something useful, thanks for the links.
I then found this very recent article https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnna...-astrology-and-the-stock-market/#2a718f261343
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top