Anyone not making 200k a year from trading is a piker

Serious answers please - A successful trader is a piker

  • if he makes less than 100k a year

    Votes: 38 52.8%
  • if he makes less than 200k a year

    Votes: 7 9.7%
  • if he makes less than 300k a year

    Votes: 6 8.3%
  • if he makes less than 500k a year

    Votes: 21 29.2%

  • Total voters
    72
Quote from RedDuke:

I agree with OP. however, I would add "and living in a developed part of the world" to the title.

You can as well remove "from trading" from the title
 
Quote from luisHK:

You can as well remove "from trading" from the title

Yes, but it is a trading forum so it is totally appropriate. My reasoning is that there are many jobs that can get you to around 150K per year doing 9-5, plus medical and vacations.

Whoever jumps into this fields, should be aiming to at least mid 6 figures, otherwise the hours and stress not worth it.
 
Hello friends.

* At my prop firm, I noticed that the hover-point average for people who start to get on their feet and become consistently profitable tends to be around the 150k-200k mark.

* Everyone hovers somewhere around this region, as long as they are profitable. Now it's hard to measure it year-to-year, but its easier to say that people eventually take around ~15k a month, for themselves, on average.

* However, after this beyond there is a significant amount of tapering off in terms of the number of people alive and how much they really aim for (i.e. there's a lot less people making the 30k to 100k per month on average).

* For example, there is a cluster of people who would get the 15k/region handled per month (for as long as they are profitable in this uncertain career) but then there are the true veterans and hard-working and/or gifted traders who can make 500k up to 5 mill a year. And you can count them all one by one.

I've been working extremely hard and through tough times as a testament to how great I would need to be in order to survive for another 10 years.

It's not easy to just scale up and whatever. Markets do change and your edge can become a different beast at any time.
 
Quote from ssrrkk:

Notice I said career job, not any job. I would define a career job as those that are pursued by people who were lucky enough to have identified what they are good at back in high school or earlier, worked hard, got into a decent school, majored in what they were driven to do, and landed a job in their field.

Then they would stick to that field for their entire career (even if they change jobs), gaining valuable experience and knowledge (i.e., knowledge that employers need to carry out their business profitably, not knowledge that you think is useful) for 30 years before they retire. Those people typically get good career jobs: relatively high level jobs (not necessarily executive but up to middle management) at large companies, or even higher level jobs at smaller companies.

Don't get me wrong, these people were not only hard-working but very lucky too, avoiding traps or major illnesses during their youth, born in an educated middle class family, received good primary and secondary education, etc. etc. Life is unfair, but basically that doesn't change the fact that there are millions and millions of people like this in the US or throughout the developed world.

I know a lot of these types, more than 50 (because I work at a fortune 500 well established company) who all make more than 150K but max out before 200K and retire. But these guys all have really fantastic retirement, health, and stock option / stock award benefits. For these guys, one would need the amount I outlined before they quit and moved to full time trading. In fact for these guys, talking about trading is akin to talking about drugs or illicit sex.

ssrrkk: That's a great point. That the very same reasoning that I quit daytrading and went back to corporate world. The risk/reward just isn't there unless you are a superstar at daytrading.

Now, I just trade on the side. Swing and daytrade. It doesn't materially affect my net worth. But I think maybe in 5-10yrs of this side compounding it might be worth something.

At least I'm beating the bank and Amex savings account by a HUGE margin. That's my benchmark. As long as I'm beating my safe alternative then it's worth trading on the side.
 
Quote from trader99:

ssrrkk: That's a great point. That the very same reasoning that I quit daytrading and went back to corporate world. The risk/reward just isn't there unless you are a superstar at daytrading.

Now, I just trade on the side. Swing and daytrade. It doesn't materially affect my net worth. But I think maybe in 5-10yrs of this side compounding it might be worth something.

At least I'm beating the bank and Amex savings account by a HUGE margin. That's my benchmark. As long as I'm beating my safe alternative then it's worth trading on the side.

ssrrkk, good points you've made. Here are the proof:

To elaborate, here are some sample salaries at a high paying tech company (Netflix). [Note: I do NOT work there.]

http://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Netflix-Los-Gatos-Salaries-EI_IE11891.0,7_IL.8,17_IC1147427.htm

Sr Software Eng $120-$275K
Dir of Eng up to $350K
VP $400K

With these salaries, there's almost NO incentives to trade. Remember, there are benefits on top of this, vacation, stock options, etc.

For someone on a good career path, to switch to trading, the payout has to be in really high. Maybe in the low 7 figures to make it worth it.
 
Quote from trader99:

ssrrkk, good points you've made. Here are the proof:

To elaborate, here are some sample salaries at a high paying tech company (Netflix). [Note: I do NOT work there.]

http://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Netflix-Los-Gatos-Salaries-EI_IE11891.0,7_IL.8,17_IC1147427.htm

Sr Software Eng $120-$275K
Dir of Eng up to $350K
VP $400K

With these salaries, there's almost NO incentives to trade. Remember, there are benefits on top of this, vacation, stock options, etc.

For someone on a good career path, to switch to trading, the payout has to be in really high. Maybe in the low 7 figures to make it worth it.

You go pick out some of the most high paying jobs and then conclude that trading is not worth it? These are not easy jobs to get. I know many people in the corporate tech world. One company in particular as I play in their sports league and there are tons of qualified smart people there with crappy jobs. Some ok director positions and even then a bunch got laid off last year and are out of work now. The only superstar is a close family member but even then hes gotta move around to get the good positions. Not easy with kids etc. Plus he's been building his resume for the last 15-20 years methodically to get the high posts he gets now. And for some reason all of his buddies and colleagues aren't making it.

But I agree, if you are making tons of money in the corporate world you would have to be an idiot to quit and start trading.
 
Quote from trader99:

ssrrkk, good points you've made. Here are the proof:

To elaborate, here are some sample salaries at a high paying tech company (Netflix). [Note: I do NOT work there.]

http://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/Netflix-Los-Gatos-Salaries-EI_IE11891.0,7_IL.8,17_IC1147427.htm

Sr Software Eng $120-$275K
Dir of Eng up to $350K
VP $400K

With these salaries, there's almost NO incentives to trade. Remember, there are benefits on top of this, vacation, stock options, etc.

For someone on a good career path, to switch to trading, the payout has to be in really high. Maybe in the low 7 figures to make it worth it.

7 figures? Not true. I've been trading full time 17+ years. I had a good secure corporate job prior to that. I would first ask WHY you'd need 7 figures to live? Unless you're into a highly materialistic lifestyle you wouldn't need that level income. I live right on the ocean in the southeast US ... no debt of any sort. Right now I'm spending a month in Maine with my wife on the ocean. I can trade wherever I want. Can the engineer, VP or other highly paid employee go wherever they want to work? Can they work only days they want? There's a lot more to life than $$$ ... the freedom trading offers can't be measured in dollars IMO. Later this morning I'll go for a run and then out kayaking. Then maybe trade a little more in the afternoon. Corporate life didn't offer that and I had both flex time and ran my own projects.
 
Back
Top