Someone could start their trading career and decide upon a certain moving average crossover system, and they might make money over a 2 year period.
But this would just be because the market conditions happened to suit their moving average choice.
That person thinks they have an aamzing edge, but soon they'll give all of their winnings back.
Someone mentioned arbitrage vs punting. I think they're right. I think that it is possible to make money trading, but just not in the way that everybody here is trying to do (including me).
I think There isn't a method or way of reading the charts that can give you any sort of edge.
Yup, a rising tide lifts all boats. We're in a 5-year long bull market so take all advice, testimonials, account statements with a grain of salt.
Agree with the arbitrage vs punting thing too.