Quote from mschey:
I am not holy crusader, I understand that there is risk in trading, and some win and some lose. Someone who deliberately put on such size with extreme leverage so as to cause risk to the entire system, and I am talking the potential of major defaults and shifting our country back into a major depression type risk, is a bad person.
I don't think you fully understand how leveraged the american economy is right now. Our system is based upon a promise to pay, nothing else. If we were to experience a sudden disruption to the system by someone failing to back their promise to pay, this could very easily spiral into and cause a system wide economic collapse. Do you even realize the amount of "off the books" derivative trades there are out there? It is many times the size of the entire stock market.
Good trading!
Mike
Obviously, the short squeeze and GM tender followed by the downgrade, was a Black Swan event when put together, back to back, get whacked on short GM position and then get whacked on the bonds on the downgrade.
Leverage is part of the game. These hedge fund managers are just players in the game. "Don't hate the player, hate the game"
This was not an "airplane trade" as you describe as to most players, it was measured and cloned by several firms. Stuff happens.
If you own a house, there was probably extreme leverage used to purchase. So much, that you only put up 5-15% down. I am sure these fund managers used a lot less leverage.
If you lose your job and default on your "highly leveraged" mortgage, are you a bad guy? What about your car loan?
Similarly, if some scheme is orchestrated for a tender offer and a short squeeze and gun at shorts to spike GM and then, suddenly the S&P downgrades the bonds right after, is this fund manager a bad guy?
With so many planes in the air, there are going to be crashes.
