Quote from TimothySykes:
Many good points made, but let me try to refute them.
1. If you'd read the book, you'd see my trading success continued long past the bubble and my short selling strategy has continued to work very well in a now 5-year old bull market.
Your 5 year return shows otherwise. You made ur bulk between 1999-2002, times that we will NEVER see again. You should be commended on keeping most of the money and being ambitious enough to trade while in college. I wish I did the same, but then, most of us did not get $12,000 at the age of 16, we had part time jobs to help pay for our own expenses.
Enough with your stats, they are all over ET. The fact is that you have been unable to make money for the last 5 years, and even when you returns are looked at closely, you have no apparent edge outside 1999-2002.
If your strategy worked, you would still be trading your fund.
2. If you learned more about my DVD, you'd see I say stay away from OTCBB and Pink Sheets--my main focus is Nasdaq smallcap, very liquid, very volatile, very executable. Recent plays include CHNR, JRJC, CPSL, ZVUE, BHIP, SCON on and on
First of all, I would NEVER buy your DVD or even listen to it. It's snake oil. Plain and simple, if your strategies were so good, you would not be selling it. Make all the excuses you want about your lack of discipline, the fact is that if your strategies still worked, you would invest in them, even hire a REAL trader to execute, if needed. Your fund would still be open.
Second, most penny stocks are OTCBB and Pink Sheets. So only trading Nasdaq small cap sub $5 stocks is not exactly a Penny Stock strategy. AMEX actually has better plays in that category. Once again, you show your lack of knowledge.
3. My critique of the hedge fund industry is from a startup's point of view. All the biggest funds have little to no idea about what's going on down here and nobody else is willing to risk their futures to tell it like it is. All I know is that industry regulations have hurt the little guy and thats infuriating.
Oh cry me a river. Maybe the SEC should grant hedge fund status to everyone.
As I have said, you have ZERO idea about the industry. If you only realized how much work, staffing, planning & legal/accounting expenses goes into setting up a REAL hedge fund. And that's prior to even putting on the first trade. Maybe it's you who does not have an idea about the other side.
4. It's true, I'm all about entertainment because I do think business and finance is fun. We are losing our youth to the wrong element--it's time somebody tried to bring them back to what really matters.
There already is a Jim Cramer. I keep trying to give you a clue, THERE IS NOTHING NEW & EXTRAORDINARY IN YOUR GAME. NOTHING!!!
Have you ever watched CNBC? So what the hell are you talking about "We are losing our youth". CNBC is all bells and whistles, with bright lights, cheerleaders, fun fun fun. It's been a steady trend for years toward making finance & business FUN.
Please let's continue this dialogue, it's not often that I have a chance to have a meaningful debate on here.
Timmay, most of the debate is with yourself. Your target audience are morons who are looking for a quick buck & unwilling to learn, put in the time and accept the reality of trading. Everyone else sees through your charade. While you need to keep up appearances, it is not logical for you to do that on ET. You simply do not have the experience or the knowledge to play this Snake Oil game with guys who have seen it before. You're getting picked apart and have been picked apart, caught lying & contradicting yourself, then trying to make lame excuses. And then you conitinue to antagonize by posting all these reviews in your desperate attempt to validate your book & yourself.