Quote from Publisher:
http://press.princeton.edu/titles/8383.html
Now Princeton professors are going to be called anti-Semites aswell?
Ridiculous.
`Publisher' is the only one who is being called on his
antisemitism here.
He has already demonstrated that the charge is true beyond any
question by his own words.
He repeats lies and falsehoods, in a transparent effort to smear `the Jews.'
When I spoke of hatred, I meant the hatred your
religion
`Publisher' is obviously completely incapable of logic.
Here's a hint:
I have no religion. I'm an atheist.
This has always been the strongest argument against the
Talmud, and Jews have systematically tried to cover it
up.
This is just so much more, utterly unoriginal, antisemitic drivel.
One can, exactly similarly, examine the canonical Christian Gospels,
in particular the Gospel of John, and come to the
equally strong
conclusion that Jesus is hostile towards `the Jews.'
In fact, it is apparent that many early Christians did come to
precisely that conclusion. See the Patristic literature, for example,
the writings of Athanasius, and Augustine, for early Christian opinion
on Jews and Judaism.
Given such a situation, and given that early Christians, who were
originally a sect of Judaism, as far as the Romans were concerned,
eventually gained political ascendancy in the Roman Empire it is
hardly surprising that there existed Jewish writers who were hostile
to Christianity, and that some of these writings were recorded in
the Talmud.
It is also no surprise that Jews at times made an effort to cover up
some of these hostile references, since they were regularly used by
antisemitic Christians as justification for persecution of Jewish
communities.
If you just admitted that the Talmud is hostile towards
Christ, that would give your religion a much more honest
reputation.
What, now `Publisher' asserts that the whole Talmud is hostile towards
Christ? He is a Talmudic scholar? Speaks Hebrew and Aramaic, and knows
the history of both Judaism and Christianity?
Here's a hint:
It does not follow from anything `Publisher'
has `Published' that `the Talmud' is hostile towards Christ.
That is a totally unjustifiable generalization.
My argument is: If you want us "anti-Semites" to take your refutations
seriously, you should stop lieing about the defamation of Jesus in the
Talmud.
Your argument has already collapsed. You are simply intellectually unequipped for
this debate.
Where have I lied? Your repetition of these lines, with the clear
implication that they prove
`the Jews' are hostile to Christ
is in itself a lie, and an effort to smear a whole people.
The reason I refered to "you" as if you were a religion is because, so
far, you have done everything in your might to defend the "devine"
religion of Hollywood.
Hollywood? Who said anything about Hollywood?
Perhaps you should ask your sister-in-faith Madonna what she thinks
about Christianity? I'd say she represents the Talmud quite
well.
`
`Publisher has become completely unhinged.
Rearden Metal was right: He should seek medical attention urgently.
Madonna is apparently a lapsed Catholic, and has an interest in
Kabbalah. Good for her. This is all irrelevant. The fact is that `Publisher' is
the one spewing vile antisemitic propaganda across this website.
Where's the promised apology?