Algos ruined day trading

During the civil war, there were spectators sitting on the hill who reported to large institutions and speculators who is winning in the battlefield. They reported it by Telegraphs or by actually riding on horses and reporting the situation. So there was always an unfair advantage to some...Some eras have better horses, and some have better cables.
using that logic you are saying the winners have the fast cables so if you dont have fast cables..automated colocated dma then u shouldnt trading. this wipes out 99% of your retail customer base. very good point indeed. thanks
 
using that logic you are saying the winners have the fast cables so if you dont have fast cables..automated colocated dma then u shouldnt trading. this wipes out 99% of your retail customer base. very good point indeed. thanks

Not really. You don't really need super fast cable.
You just need to enter early.

Let me give example gold trading.

Best time is buy gold in say 1970 and you would be earning billions of dollars.

If you missed buying gold in 1970, that's ok as
you could have bought gold in 2002 and you would still be earning millions of dollars.

If you missed buying gold in 1970 and you went to buy gold in 2011, then
you would be grinding your teeth in great pain.

so having fast internet / cable is not really a prerequisite
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe I heard Marty Schwartz said in one of his later interviews that he couldn't trade today's markets or at least not as profitably as he used to. He used to day trade S&P futures and very successfully.

The market still moves from A to B - but perhaps the path from A to B has changed? I have followed ES futures on and off for around 10 years and I have the feeling that the market is more choppy and retraces more in later years. But I have no real proof of it, so I can't really say.

As long as the market still moves and you're able to buy/sell (liquidity) - I can't see why day trading is ruined, but it sure might be a different market today than when Ned Davis was young.
 
Not really. You don't really need super fast cable.
You just need to enter early.

Let me give example gold trading.

Best time is buy gold in say 1970 and you would be earning billions of dollars.

If you missed buying gold in 1970, that's ok as
you could have bought gold in 2002 and you would still be earning millions of dollars.

If you missed buying gold in 1970 and you went to buy gold in 2011, then
you would be grinding your teeth in great pain.

so having fast internet / cable is not really a prerequisite
lmao. um. you must talking about physical gold and once you pull out storage insurance transport security cost over all those years which is called BASIS in the futures market then you lose and the broker is not talking about making trades for years at a time. i am dumbfounded if these people on here actually trade and scratch their heads when they LOSE. wow.
 
Algos don't ruin my day trading.



because I focus on charts.
I don't do arbitrage, and I don't look at order flow.


In fact, no day traders ruin my day trading.
Only one who ruin my day trading is me and my innerself.


Blame thyself, not others.


%% HOW DARE you blame yourself?? LOL-LOL Charts help. I don't blame others also-its counter productive
 
using that logic you are saying the winners have the fast cables so if you dont have fast cables..automated colocated dma then u shouldnt trading. this wipes out 99% of your retail customer base. very good point indeed. thanks

This is your logic.

What I meant is that there was no time in history that someone did not have an advantage, yet, there are always great traders and investors who do not focus on what they do not have, instead what they do have and make the best out of it. For example, If you do have a model that requires automation and you do not have DMA+colocation+exchnage membership, yes, it would make it difficult to compete. On the other hand, if you do not, retail traders have (in my opinion) adequate routing technologies available to them.
 
If something gets ruined it is because at least 1 essential element is missing.
That's so for anything you do in life.

If your daytrading is ruined at least 1 essential element is missing. It can be anything, no necessarily algos. Markets became more professional and way of trading changed a lot when computers arrived, when the internet arrived, when commissions went lower due to competition, etc...
20years ago almost nobody could daytrade because of the financial requirements, today even a bump can "daytrade" bitcoins as he has a mobile phone and can buy/sell 0.00001 bitcoin.
 
Back
Top