As for your self-serving distaste of "anyone who claims to be using a method", I say screw you!
You want some input about MY trading life... add volume to YOUR posts! I have very little to say trade-wise without it.

ET has become a 17th century Witchcraft court...
tie up the witch and throw them into a body of water.
If they sink they are innocent, if they float they are guilty.
The practice was called "swimming a witch".
Many thanks for your input as always Rams Fan.Having seen that video Al Brooks video posted earlier in this thread, I suspect that he is not much of a trader. He knows what to do, but when it comes to putting his own money or even his own reputation on the line, he is unable to do so. That is my current assessment of Brooks as a trader.
However, his trading course is not compromised by his own psychological failings.
You display some very perceptive thinking here: Especially the part that our human nature is willing to gamble with losses but we are afraid to gamble with the risk of losing our profit.Interesting. When was that?
I'll emphasize one thing. Note the bold part in what I wrote:
Even if you know what to do, you'll often find that as a discretionary trader you may not always be able to do it. Trading is rigged against human nature. We want to be right and we're willing to gamble with losses while taking certain (and small) wins. Check out prospect theory.
I'm not afraid to admit that it will still happen that after a second or third add-on, I won't always be able to take the breakeven exit and give it some extra room to breathe.
The one rule I seem to be able to follow religiously is that I never average down.
The problem with averaging down is that it can surprisingly often work, but the few times it don't, you will take that huge loss.
I'm guilty of constantly teasing on ET about hershey and especially his frequent mentions to volume analysis.
Dude, no matter whether he made money or not, you shouldn't treat the deceased that way. That's extremely rude and disrespectful.Jack Hershey died a number of years ago (2016 or thereabouts?). Somebody posted the obit which included his address. The house was a ghetto shack in some one-horse town in Arizona. If memory serves, Hershey's primary disciple on ET (who naturally claimed to be pulling down 2-3x the ATR every day out of the Emini futures market) was eventually doxxed as a convicted sex offender who managed a small campground in the Southwest.
tl;dr Hershey never made a dime trading, and anyone who claims to make consistent money applying his nonsensical principles is lying.
Jack Hershey died a number of years ago (2016 or thereabouts?). Somebody posted the obit which included his address. The house was a ghetto shack in some one-horse town in Arizona. If memory serves, Hershey's primary disciple on ET (who naturally claimed to be pulling down 2-3x the ATR every day out of the Emini futures market) was eventually doxxed as a convicted sex offender who managed a small campground in the Southwest.
tl;dr Hershey never made a dime trading, and anyone who claims to make consistent money applying his nonsensical principles is lying.
Do you think that your success as a Trader is due moreso to your experience