@padutrader you know Al better than most, why would he do that? Seems stupid, both from a trading perspective, but also from an advertising perspective.
I had never seen that video before today and I would say it is unquestionably a disaster.
"Most beginners cannot do this. Most experienced traders
do not do this. But a trader who understands what's going on and they know the odds of the market pulling back to the moving average can do this."
You'd have to ask Brooks himself why he made this video and why he thought it should be posted to the internet.
He starts "I took a trade today in one of my actual trading accounts ... to illustrate how to manage scaling into a losing trade."
He purposefully took what he felt would be a losing trade so he could illustrate how to do something that no beginner can do, and most experienced traders have enough sense
not to do?
Strains credulity, if I May say so.
The chart shows a tight bull channel, followed by an 8 bar, 2 leg pull back and an H2 buy signal. There are countless slides in his course where this is a BUY, not a SHORT SALE.
He does, throughout the course mention that most days, on a five minute chart, price will trade to its 20 ema. I do not recall that that was ever used in the course as justification to make a counter trend trade when the market is in breakout mode. Use your imagination to picture what that 20 bar rally on the five minute looked like on a 15 minute or an hourly chart: big bull candles closing near their highs.
In my opinion, in this video, Brooks is full of himself: "So it's reasonable to sell," he says repeatedly. No, it was not
reasonable. This isn't even a sell according to the scalping method he includes in his course because when scalping on, say, a two minute bar chart, he would tell you to scalp in the direction of the five minute ema.
I do not use the moving average on my charts. But if I did, I would not be inclined to short when the ema is rising and the market is in breakout mode.
Brooks does himself, his course, and people like me who would advocate for the value of studying his course no good service by posting this video of an exceedingly poor trade. The fact that he took a poor trade isn't the real offense. The offense is he published a 13 minute video attempting to justify it.
Why not just keep it private?
What sort of ego compelled him to publish an example of such poor price action judgement and repeatedly to justify it?
I stand by my opinion on the value of the content of his video course. This video here is not at all like anything contained in the video course. I'm very, very disappointed in Brooks's decision to make and post such a video as this, to say the least.