Quote from Anekdoten:
Take a poll, ask the readers.
Personally, I think you are full of it. I use personal tools to enhance the trading. I've always said it will never be a requirement.
Tell you what, please leave my journal, I no longer welcome you here.
Anek
Of course you are free to believe what you want, but I have not changed my strategy or chart layout one iota since implementing it several years back. You on the other hand, preach price action without the need for indicators, yet cling to them like bark to a tree. There's no denying you have been shedding most of them as you discover they simply do not enhance your trading, precisely what I have said all along, but nice spin.
At the beginning of the thread:
http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/attachment.php?s=&postid=1537294
You are currently down to nothing but a naked bar chart, but still clinging to some magical indicator. There may be hope yet!
http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/attachment.php?s=&postid=1585464
I am a great believer in expanding ones horizons, but constantly changing everything on your charts and trying everything that comes down the pike is not conducive to helping others learn; that was your purpose here, was it not? In fact, it tells me you are not sure of yourself or are still struggling. That's not a negative comment, as we are always learning as we go.
Many on ET are still glassy eyed and want to believe the holy grail actually exists. They want to believe you really do have some magical method that lights your path. You are doing them a disservice saying you are trading using price action, and you are going to teach them how, and then reveal in a boasting manner about how you have this mystical indicator that you can't reveal.
When I called you out on it, only after you made asinine insinuations I might add, you sidestepped the issue. I posted a hypothetical chart marked with various entries and asked you to show how your indicator would improve on those. Instead, you cut and paste some idiotic red dots void of explanation and instead started with the insinuations again. Actually marking a chart showing where and how your indicator helps make better entries would have been more beneficial to your followers and would have put me in my place. Seems you were unable to do that though. Of course, you don't have to prove anything to anyone, nor do I. But it does put a smell of bull$hit in the air when you make statements and then won't back them up.
Your insinuations this morning were uncalled for, and had they not been said, I would have dropped this thread and moved on at some point. The only reason I began posting again recently is because I was receiving so many PM's, many questioning your methods. I replied back to each and everyone and said I did not want to be counterproductive or confuse anyone by going against what you were teaching, but I did answer what I thought was right privately.
Bottom line, you poke me, I poke back. Spread bull$hit, and I'll call you out on it. There is an ignore button some where, I'm sure someone will be glad to point it out to you.
st
