Quote from Ivanovich:
Yeah, so much for that "top is in" call, eh? Can I move it to chit chat now to burn in flames with all the other hundreds of top calls?
do whatever you like, after all, you're the moderator.
an after hours move, may or may not hold by tomorrow morning. based on today's close 1057, there are still 2 higher highs. the first post called the wednesday 2 weeks ago as the top, with an interday high of 1080. the pevious day's high was the highest closing high of about 1073
so based on closing prices, we're still about 16 points below it
based on intraday (and after hours prices, current ah ES is about 17 points below the intraday high
so, it's not broken yet, although i am surprised by the AH move. I have not been surprised by anything up until the close today
next key levels (IMO) would be 1067, last month's 20 month average, a sticking point for much of the month, the higest close or 1073, then 1080. i would consider the call wrong at that point, the top was either in or it's not. if it goes above 1080, or closes above 1973 the call is wrong. (Even if they close the month below the new 20 month average, and drop it like a rock afterward)
I started this thread knowing i'd take flack on the top call. if it's wrong, it's wrong. but it isnt wrong yet
http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&threadid=177870
"09-30-09 09:02 PM
technical case is i this thread
the actual top was last wednesday, today's close confirms it
"