Advice

Automate your trading using the rules from your extraordinary system and by doing that you'll take discipline right out of the equation.

One of our sponsors is a successful trader named Kevin Davey and his website is https://kjtradingsystems.com/. He teaches a workshop on how to automate your trading and write your ruleset into TradeStation using EasyLanguage.

Another quality sponsor we have here at ET is one that literally wrote the book on EasyLanguage. His name is Murray Ruggiero and his website is https://www.usingeasylanguage.com/

And finally, Alpaca offers a web-based API service for writing your system rules and automatically executing your trades commission-free through their brokerage division.

Good luck!

Will check them out. Thanks!.
 
Good question and better criticism. Not overconfident but definitely complacent.
After wich event do you get complacent? After amount of dollars or after a number of winnings in a row? Do you let your focus go after that event? Are you bored with executions?
 
After wich event do you get complacent? After amount of dollars or after a number of winnings in a row? Do you let your focus go after that event? Are you bored with executions?
Don't understand the question re bored with executions, and re complacency it's a combination of the $ and the wins. In either event, clearly not concerned enough with a loss to force discipline into the equation either before the entry or when I understand it was a bad one.
 
Don't understand the question re bored with executions, and re complacency it's a combination of the $ and the wins. In either event, clearly not concerned enough with a loss to force discipline into the equation either before the entry or when I understand it was a bad one.
Okay, I think to know where you are. You are trading not for the results in money but for some unresolved issue you have with yourself and how you see yourself. You need someone that can let you see how you react and make you self aware when this proces start in your trading. When you recognised it, you can take several action to avoid it. This is not a discipline issue.
 
Hello All
Need some advice. Please. No BS.
I have thank Goodness an extraordinary system. The problem is I have shit discipline. Everything goes well for a few days/weeks, and then I make a mistake and destroy the balance. And it's always one of the same three mistakes. And they're dipshit stupid mistakes: Badly timed entry( before news), playing with the stop, or refusing to exit even when I know I'm wrong.
I'm fortunately not stupid (though you could argue stupid is as stupid does *Forest Gump), the opposite. FWIW, I'm a genius. Not arrogance, just a fact and part of the "story".
I know all the psychology about humility and admitting when you're wrong, etc. and have no issue with that. It's just I'm sure it will turn around and truth be told it 90% of the time does. But usually only after f$%&^%g my account balance.
So any advice would be appreciated.
TIA.

p.s. I trade scalp/short term. Generally under 10 minutes per entry.

You dont have an extraordinary system. You need to examine and improve your trading plan.

What you have sounds like it both relies on human discretion but is not robust enough for human decision factors and normal errors. Telling someone to have better discipline is the same as dieting for a fat person. It wont work long term.

My guess is the problem is your timeframe. If your approach is any good take it up to a longer timeframe allowing more decision time and less random volatility/noise.
 
Telling someone to have better discipline is the same as dieting for a fat person. It wont work long term.

Telling an overweight person he should diet, might not work, but isn't it exactly what he should do?
There are many reasons that people get to be overweight, and it could range from bad habits, personal trauma or physiological and hormonal changes. But, in the final analysis, only proper diet and exercise are what make a person lose weight.

Changing time frames, methods, etc may reflect the same issues again in a different format.
I agree with you that time frames do make a difference for some, and sometimes the method needs tweaking. But I think that the way the OP described it, it could be behavioral.
 
I know all the psychology about humility and admitting when you're wrong, etc. and have no issue with that. It's just I'm sure it will turn around and truth be told it 90% of the time does. But usually only after f$%&^%g my account balance.

Your answer is in your own words. Your sharp and you realize the odds are strongly in favor of a rebound in your direction, thus your willing to override your own rules. The problem is : The 10% "non rebounds" eat your account, and a future "black swan" may destroy it.
 
See we have the exact same issue, sadly not a genius 4 IQ points short here :( good enough.

That 1 trade, you get a bias, it goes the wrong way, you keep moving the SL and before you realise it you've been margin called.

Just got to push yourself, to do the right thing, which is Exit and Flip and give up on HOPE, I'm not there yet mind, getting there, final peice in my puzzle I hope.
 
Back
Top