About that so called 'birth announcement'

Quote from KavonTrebor:

NOt case law but the 14th Amendment:

All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside."

A case to look at:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Wong_Kim_Ark

enjoy
14th amendment does not address natural born citizen requirement. It does speak to naturalized citizens - which is a different concept.

Natural born citizen is quite likely a much tougher requirement to meet than citizen.
 
Quote from jem:

14th amendment does not address natural born citizen requirement. It does speak to naturalized citizens - which is a different concept.

Natural born citizen is quite likely a much tougher requirement to meet than citizen.

I believe the principal of "jus soli" prevails as well as many Supreme Court Cases say basically if you are born in the USA you are a citizen.
 
Quote from KavonTrebor:

I believe the principal of "jus soli" prevails as well as many Supreme Court Cases say basically if you are born in the USA you are a citizen.

Good news! You're right!

That still doesn't make him a natural born citizen, though, which is the test for president.
 
Quote from Aletheia:

1. Provide a verifiable source that legally defines natural born citizen in the scenario you described and the offsprings eligibility to hold office of POTUS.

2. In the scenario you describe, would the child be legally entitled to dual citizenship, and if so, can a person entitled to dual citizenship be POTUS under the letter of the law?

3. Setting aside party line differences, as US citizens, why should we the people as a whole, not hold candidates for POTUS to the same standards as those who will serve under him/her?


Still waiting............all I hear are crickets in response to the above.
 
I guess BO is unconcerned about the birth issue but is really concerned about releasing all his records... so he's hiding things there, like maybe he claimed to not be a citizen to get some school money or something.. he sure is a lying POS from the get go, I'd assume he'd lie to get some freebie education or to jump the waiting line for entrance or whatever... he probably thinks that lying is the normal language for people and can't understand the fuss...

People voted for him so he could fight the big corporations or whatever, and he puts Wall Street in charge of the White House... this presidency is as bizarre as the Carter one, absolutely bizarre... Carter was an absolute 33rd degree Masonic Minion of the New World Order and he did the most bizarre things.. I think it was on his watch that China somehow was given control of the Port of Long Beach or some weird assed deal like that.. I just tuned out the entire Carter years.. I remember it, no TV, radio, forget it, the lying weirdo's are in charge, no real reason to try to figure them out... I had a job and some cars I used to fix all the time and girl friends... I really don't recall those years that much..
 
How I wish we could magically know how many birthers also believe that 9-11 was an inside job planned by George and Barbara Bush with the assistance of their two daughters, who were circling the Twin Towers in a black helicopter on the day of the 'attacks'. Wanna do an over/under on the correlation?
 
Quote from traderNik:

How I wish we could magically know how many birthers also believe that 9-11 was an inside job planned by George and Barbara Bush with the assistance of their two daughters, who were circling the Twin Towers in a black helicopter on the day of the 'attacks'. Wanna do an over/under on the correlation?

9/11 and birthers are not comparable. The world had some genuine conspiracies, best example being assassination of julius caesar.

If you analyze means motive and opportunity birthers arguments fall apart.

Obama did not have the means to cover up his background with a sitting republican president and republican governor of hawaii. Karl Rove stopped at nothing in terms of destroying people's lives. I am supposed to believe that Karl Rove, W, McCain, Palin, FNC, RNC, Talk Radio all just stood down. The same scumbags gave the jeremia wright and bill ayers full air time but the most explosive issue possible(if true) they ignore.
 
Quote from IShopAtPublix:
9/11 and birthers are not comparable. The world had some genuine conspiracies, best example being assassination of julius caesar.

If you analyze means motive and opportunity birthers arguments fall apart.
Are you suggesting that 9-11 George/Barbara Bush black helicopter theories are somehow more 'genuine' than birther conspiracy theories?

If you analyze 'means, motive and opportunity', do 9-11 theories hold together??

I think you can draw a straight line right through 9-11 tinfoil hatters to their birther cousins.
 
Quote from Aletheia:

1. Provide a verifiable source that legally defines natural born citizen in the scenario you described and the offsprings eligibility to hold office of POTUS.

2. In the scenario you describe, would the child be legally entitled to dual citizenship, and if so, can a person entitled to dual citizenship be POTUS under the letter of the law?

3. Setting aside party line differences, as US citizens, why should we the people as a whole, not hold candidates for POTUS to the same standards as those who will serve under him/her?

<object width="425" height="344"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/d3sROOA6fv8&hl=en&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/d3sROOA6fv8&hl=en&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="425" height="344"></embed></object>
 
Quote from traderNik:

How I wish we could magically know how many birthers also believe that 9-11 was an inside job planned by George and Barbara Bush with the assistance of their two daughters, who were circling the Twin Towers in a black helicopter on the day of the 'attacks'. Wanna do an over/under on the correlation?

I would be labled a "birther", and I do not think 9/11 was an inside job.

I am going to request a new label..." Documentationist"......

Try getting a job with a security clearance without having your records checked and verified, and since Mr. Obama is being paid by the taxpayers, this information should be public record.

"Where's the documents ?"

Change we can believe in !
 
Back
Top