The thing is Swordsman, you are absolutly wrong. Do you really think he is intersted in defending himself? Do you really think that he is sad that he was exposed as not being a trader? Do you really think he is a trader? Does anyone?
Why do you think he posts here? It isn't to prove that he is a great trader. Suprisingly enough, it isn't even to prove that Jack Hershey and his followers are complete fools who cant trade. It isn't even some greater good trying to save us newbies from wasting our time with Hershey.
Quite plainly he is here to troll. All of you are just feeding him. He picks on the Hershey traders simply because you people are the only ones that consistantly respond to him. He starts all these threads bashing Jack, SCT, PVT, Spyders dress, Steve's 911 story, Cocaine's wealthy comment...etc...etc...etc because you people line up to take up his challenge. But that is the problem. You all can't really see what the challenge is all about.
He isn't challenging you all to prove that you are traders, or that he isn't a trader, or that your method works, or that he never posts trades, or that you do have proof you are a good trader. He is a troll, and his challenge is simple. He is challenging you all to not respond to him.
FYI, you are all failing miserably.
God help me, but let me quote his recent post. I know this will feed him a little, but lets think of it like a zoo. It sucks that we lock a bunch of animals up in cages, but perhaps the people that visit will learn something, and overall things will be beter. So, in hopes that is becomes completely clear:
Quote from schlap:
I blew you all out of the water, long and short.. want to count how many posts you've all made to me
Today I highlighted the fact that none of you understand price action and none of you take trades
Look at what he wrote. Take a look at the first sentence. He absolutely did blow you all out of the water! Did he blow you out of the water with his trading prowess? Did he blow you up by proving your method was bilk? Or was it something else?
"want to count how many posts you've all made to me
"If you want to truly be rid of him, there is only one way to do it. Realize what he is here for, and STOP RESPONDING. Dont start threads getting people to commit to not responding to him, it only feeds him. Don't post messages pointing out that he deleted posts which proves he can't trade, it only feeds him. Hell, don't even delete his accounts, because that doesn't work either, again, it only feeds him.
We all know he can't trade. We all know he brings absolutely nothing to the table as far as this forum is concerened. And in there somewhere we all know he is only trying to get us to respond. Think about that. He only wants a response.
So if you truly want to be rid of him, and help to constrain the polution of this site, there is only one solution. It is easy as hell too...or at least should be...DO NOTHING.
BBQ
