Quote from jjgallow:
Thank you kindly Apex,
Let me first say that, despite our opposite sentiments, I really appreciate your expertise. Hopefully, if we trade well, we can both make money even though one of us will be fighting the market to make it, lol.
You've given me a lot to mull over, but what struck me most noticeably was the rule of wave 4 not crossing wave 1.
thank you apex
Thanks again for the remarks. Well we can definately both profit having different sentiments, so that is definately a plus.
Im going to be blunt and honest with you. I only use ew analysis when it is clear as day. When something is kinda fishy or could be this, could be that I just ignore it and concentrate on other factors. You will find its very subjective so its best to just stick with the bare basics.
In a classic elliot wave, yes, wave 4 must not overlap wave 1. This is why I disagree with the chart you posted at the end of your post. I would call that a wedge. A 5 wave move where wave 4 overlaps wave 1.
With a typical ewave, wave 3 is the most extended. So in oil, I would say its unlikely that its just completing a wave 4 if I am understanding your count correctly. (see attached chart to see if this is the wave count you were thinking of)
I like how you made the comment "less likely" at the end of your post. This shows that your thinking with odds and probabilities and not sure things. The truth is, oil can do whatever it wants, but it is your goal as a trader to accumulate edges and trade with probabilities in your favour.
Best Regards,
Apex
