Quote from LongShot:
i dont know, but it sure makes us feel a lot better if we can make rational sense of it.
If we are to speak to it at all we must use [Earthly] concepts and language to do so otherwise nothing could be said; other than unconditional belief you could say nothing more.
You would have to be quiet about the whole matter. The moment you open your mouth to say one thing about it you open the door to allow for other possible earthly attributes and logical conundrums and the like.
Either speak and think about it, or just believe quietly in blind faith. You cant have it both ways.![]()
The problem is that you want it only going one direction. If you look at the beginning of this thread, the theists were generally cordial in my opinion. However, the atheists were venomous. Here's a few examples:
"The devil doesn't exist. Satan is manufactured by the minds of people for at least two purposes.
1. to use as a tool to attempt to control people with fear.
2. to have something else to cast blame on instead of accepting responsibilty for ones own actions: the devil made me do it.
However, a 666 moving average can exist - if it's helpful to you then use it." --Plumlazy
"my death or "afterlife" is the same as an ant's, a dog's, a worm's, the pope's, or adolf hitler's. when the pope dies, his afterlife or death will be exactly what adolf hitler got. that is the same i will get. that is the same we all will get NO MATTER WHAT CRAP YOU BELIEVE OR WERE BRAINWASHED INTO BELIEVING." --GG
"if you want an epiphany, rid yourself of religious crap and read some science books." --GG
"Yes yes... like live active volcanos created by GOD, with lava
flows which spurt out and burn innocent babies to death
in unimaginable horrific ways. To top it off, he KNEW this would
happen BEFORE he created the volcano since he is omniscient.
What a nice god" --axe
"Don't take the story literally Gekko. It's a parable." --dgagabriel
"My unicorn completely agrees with you." --TMTrader
I contend that noone knows what happened in the first 10-34 seconds of the universe.
I think you can see where I am going: it is fine for you to say that I must believe, i.e. must have "faith." But you are in the same boat. You must also "believe" in your position as to the beginning of the universe.
I am willing to be honest and say that I "believe" in God, that I must have a certain element of "faith" (which is NOT to say that I think there is no evidence for the divine). However, what chaps my posterior is that you guys act as if you KNOW what happened in the first 10-34 seconds of the universe, almost as if you were there!
Maybe I missed it, but I have not yet seen one of you guys admit that your atheistic beliefs are based on "faith" just as much as mine.
So I reply to you as well, "Either speak and think about it, or just believe quietly in blind faith. You cant have it both ways."
