2009: The Bull Market in Gold

Quote from Debaser82:

On a historical basis gold during deflation outperforms gold during inflation.

:)
How would you know ? there has never been a deflationary period since Bretton Woods ... duh !
Gold is now like any other commodity. Commodities don't rise in deflation. period.
 
Quote from naufal:Consumer wealth destruction does not translate into demand destruction of gold, like it does for oil. Gold's demand is from banks and speculators and people who want to preserve capital.
What percentage of Gold is used in Jewellery, Industry and Investment?
Around 70% of gold demand is jewelery, 11% is industrial (dental, electronics) and 13% is investment (institutional and individual, bars & coins).

http://www.gold.org/faq/answer/94/w..._is_used_in_jewellery_industry_and_investment
 
Quote from cvds16:

How would you know ? there has never been a deflationary period since Bretton Woods ... duh !
Gold is now like any other commodity. Commodities don't rise in deflation. period.

Then why is gold up year to date in what as been described also in this topic as a period of "record deflation"?

A glitch?

Might want to compare gold VS CRB.

Deflation? Gold is money so it gains in purchasing power.

Inflation? Gold is a hedge against monetary debasement.

Financial/geopolitical crisis? Gold is good regardless of inflation/deflation.
 
spoken like a true gold bug: you always have to buy gold ! Inflation, deflation, no matter what ...
slight problem gold bugs always forget: in the long run gold is always one of the worst investments ...
 
and for the record: deflation started only a few months ago for the biggest part of the world: exactly the months gold has been going down ...
 
Quote from cvds16:

spoken like a true gold bug: you always have to buy gold ! Inflation, deflation, no matter what ...
slight problem gold bugs always forget: in the long run gold is always one of the worst investments ...

No, you can have periods of low inflation and geopolitical stability where gold is indeed one of the worst investments out there.

Although you could view such periods as the perfect buying opportunity indeed.:D

Quote from cvds16:

and for the record: deflation started only a few months ago for the biggest part of the world: exactly the months gold has been going down ...

Gold in euro:

09/01/2008 566.6140

12/29/2008 620.5880

Gold in USD:

09/01/2008 831.20

12/29/2008 880.480

Gold in GBP:

09/01/2008 456.6230

12/29/2008 598.0130
 
Quote from silk:

We have near record deflation right now. The credit bubble propped up all prices with unsustainable debt driven demand and now prices for many things are crashing back down. Gold may be no different. If people are losing their jobs and have less money, are they going to go out and buy gold with what few dollars they have left? I doubt it. More likely they will be taking their jewlery to the pawn shop and hocking their gold so that they can buy food and pay the rent.

It is not relevant i think to speculate about impending hyperinflation when we are currenty having record deflation. Maybe when prices stop falling and the economy starts improving and we still see the GVT spending tons of extra money then that would be a huge concern.

GVT actions certainly are inflationary, but I think they are inflationary from a much lower base that the economy is currently crashing toward. If it wasn't for the credit bubble, perhaps normal prices of things would be say DOW 6000, Crude $29, Gold $500, home prices 1998 levels, milk $2.00...ECT ECT. The GVT is actually trying to inflate these prices so that we don't crash down as far. This is a good plan I think because if prices do keep crashing down to what may be the true levels, this will be a terrible depression.

So while gvt policy may be creating hyperinflation, it may be hyperinflation on what true prices are that we are CRASHING down to and not current spot prices which are still too high and falling daily in this post credit bust world.

Well put, and I concur.

IMHO the debt deflation and demand destruction issues are so significant that they are dwarfing the otherwise 'hyper' inflationary money supply growth as a result of TARP, bailouts, whatever. Print at 20% but destroy at 25% you are still down 5%.

I am still surprised that gold has maintained its value well in this period, making me suspect that we are not near the end of this yet (still too much liquid cash around).

The main problem is 'overshoot' - what happens in 2011, 2012 and onward. But that's too far off for prognostication, so you are just best off reacting and making some moderate preliminary plans.
 
Quote from silk:

Money supply is tough to measure.

Are you stupid or have just been in a cave for the last year?

Did you miss the bailout news? 7 trillion dollars to be injected, close to a trillion has already been put to work.

Let me see some deflation on food prices, meesdical & electricity. You won't find any. Because the printing press are working overtime, and those new printed dollars will find their way to key goods regardless of banks restricting liquidity. Just cause Joe Blow is not getting the easy credit anymore, does not mean it's not going around.

Hoarding cash is a sucker move right now, plain and simple. It never makes sense to save worthless inked paper.
 
Add to the fact that deflation will be perceived if capital is being moved out and exchanged for other currencies.

Not everything has to be dollars to gold

Deflation as perceived by the U.S. consumer is here for 09.

Also, too many people group all prices into one lump, either up or down. There

Yes Inflation from an Austrian view is occurring, but I think the deleveraging forces are so powerful right now, and this process will take time before the excess liquidity takes place.

Unless the govt starts mailing checks for $500,000 to every american, it will be a while before this liquidity hits the lower levels. Right now all the capital is being held by the powers that be.

Also too many assume the govt will just keep printing, that they wont remove the liquidity at some point. Thats also niave. High Inflation yes, but Wheimar or Zimbabwe highly unlikely.

Still even a 30 % devlaution of the dollar will be painful.
 
Back
Top