I'm new here, but second what gertsman said about the "anal-ness" of some on ET. Often it seems like women sitting around talking on who has the better set-up in their love lives... more money, jewelry and the like (no offense women) and similar pettiness.
On the other hand ET is a great place; sure glad I found it... wish I'd heard of it years ago!! Good place to make some new friends and we can never have enough of those.
Think everyone on here has an obligation as a member to offer what they can... those reasonably or highly successful traders IMHO have some small obligation to "pay it forward".... by sharing with others who are rookies, are struggling or in need of direction. If they are too selfish, or unwilling to make some small contributions from time to time... rather than just posting hints about how good they are, how big their positions and/or trades are, and ostensibly only seeking to impress... while being able to read and review all other input from knowledgeable and experienced traders.. then they should just be ignored.
Thus, if "Gertsman" wants to stay private, I respect that. But if he posts about 75K day trading..... he ought to be willing to share just a little strategy, philosophy... etc. with others without being defensive in saying they expect too much.
But that is a value judgment he's got to make.
It's my view that "membership" (even an online website) still carries with it an obligation to share. Maybe that is just an old-fashioned (or outmoded) value that doesn't apply to "wizard traders!"
Ice
