10 Days With TopStepTrader

Status
Not open for further replies.
Quote from austinp:

attachment.php


I finished this combine net profitable, but unsuccessful to qualify for review. There was never any question about ending profitable to some degree… just a matter of operating inside the combine limits or not. Profitable ending part was assured.

The trade management strategy I attempted from early on was to work from a rather fast setting chart for precision type entries using 2 and 3 contracts split across spread fills where it makes technical sense. Also, I attempted to trade pause-pullback entry fills around key S/R values.

That strategy to manage 5-lot and 10-lot size failed to work. In the sideways erratic nature of recent price action, the deliberate entry attempts at key S/R zones went unfilled as price blew thru and sailed away repeatedly. Also, the relatively fast charts didn’t provide precision signals, they still got blown away on fill attempts or worse, chopped in sideways ranges.

Aug 9th began with $900+ peak equity early
Aug 12th began with $900+ peak equity early
Aug 13th began with $600+ peak equity early

Then each day proceeded to blow thru entry attempts unfilled, and or chopped trade attempts in between unfilled orders.

So the max drawdown was reached Aug 13th that negated review of this combine.

**

At that time it was clear my initial strategy to work this program was incorrect on several fronts. P&L explained that to me quite clearly. So the adjustments I made were changing chart to slower relative setting (500 volume) and splitting orders 4-lot / 6-lot around fewer signals. I also went with 100% momentum breakout entries and nixed the pullback attempts which clearly do not work in explosive CL tapes at this present time.

End result of those simple adjustments was $9,000+ added from trough low draw to this morning prior to midday CL selloff dive. Had I traded further today into that signaled move, add $5,000 or more to end tally there.

**

I’ll trade one more combine program, sometime in early September past Labor Day. Too busy with other tasks right now until then the way it stands tonight, subject to change. If I work with TST in that effort, will report here on a daily basis but if not, will report on a week-end basis each Friday.

I don’t personally prefer to chronicle daily performance because it errantly places too much emphasis on each day’s outcome which means nothing at all. Less than nothing, actually. I focus on weekly and monthly results. Focus on daily results will result in too much emotional angst for any trader, imo

But either way is fine and I’ll be sure to chronicle the process here (and elsewhere) from start and finish.

So that’s how it went. Will be back with a 100k or 150k campaign in the manner described above. I like my chances very much of running the trade entry/orders in exact same mode that final three sessions were executed. Taking losses on 4-lots at -10 cent stops or taking profits on 10-lots for much more than that :cool:


enough sim talk.....i cannot find anywhere on your website how much real dollars you made in your trading career ,do you have besides sim trades and talk anything of substance ?
 
Quote from Peternam:

enough sim talk.....i cannot find anywhere on your website how much real dollars you made in your trading career ,do you have besides sim trades and talk anything of substance ?

I prefer the simulator talk because its exactly what many here at ET requested him to do...the TST combine regardless to the fact that austinp will use the opportunity to achieve a few goals he stated earlier. Simply, let him finish that project (catering to the demands of others here at ET) involving TST combine and you should start a separate discussion thread about his website.

That keeps the mudslinging out of this thread.

Lets encourage him to succeed and just maybe others will be inspired to try harder via saying..."Geesh, if a vendor can do it...I should be able to make it too". Anyways, I see a lot of journal threads showing up at ET lately...I hope everyone eventually makes it.
 
Quote from wrbtrader:

I prefer the simulator talk because its exactly what many here at ET requested him to do...the TST combine. Simply, let him finish that project (catering to the demands of others here at ET) involving TST combine and you should start a separate discussion thread about his website.

That keeps the mudslinging out of this thread.

Thank you for trying to keep things honest.

We have this cult of demanding real time calls to prove you are any good.

If your calls are dud, the mob feeds on your carcass.

If they are good, then comes the demand for proof that it is real and not sim. Show blotters please.

Then if those prove good, the photoshop accusations arise. Of course if you show a P&L or audited account we'll believe you.

If you give in and play the game, it's a downward spiral.

It's a mugs game, plain and simple.
 
austin (any anyone else doing the combine) if profit targets are the same whether you do a 10 day combine or a 20 day, why choose the shorter time frame where you have to work 2x harder than necessary (if one approaches the combine as a means to prove yourself to outside money rather than ego)? The 100k combine is 8500 profit either way, but that translates to 425/day avg net vs 850.
 
Quote from JamesL:
----why choose the shorter time frame....
----you have to work 2x harder....
----100k combine is 8500 profit either way....
----425/day avg net vs 850.
1) By doing the 10-day instead of the 20-day, you get it over and done with faster. You have to have a "willingness" to be more aggressive, sooner, if you fall behind the average daily profit pace. :cool:
2) People who focus on the lesser "average profit per day" of the 20-day might have less motivation than those who opt for the 10-day. :eek:
3) That change amounted to a price increase for those who still opt for the 10-day Combine. :(
4) To trade 20 days instead of 10 days requires more "exposure" to the market where flaws in you method can be exposed. If some type of change in trend, volatility and/or liquidity occurs during days 11-20, to your detriment, you could be regretful about not choosing the 10-day. :mad:
5) People might be better off to start the Combine in the smaller account sizes to merely get comfortable with it and then possibly go into the larger accounts when they feel comfortable with the rules/constraints. :)
 
The easiest should be the 30K Combine as you only need a 5% return on capital to pass.

Trading the 100K requires 8.5% but the 150k only requires 8%.
 
Quote from deaddog:
----easiest should be the 30K....
----only need a 5% return on capital to pass.
----Trading the 100K....
----150k....
1) That's a mathematical "deception". Arithmetically, it seems easiest to pass because of its "lower" profit goal. :eek:
2) You're underestimating how "close and near" the daily and overall loss limits are with the 30K. When you become funded, the weekly loss limit becomes another "burden" too. :cool:
3) The loss limits on the 100K and 150K are "more valuable" after you become funded. You have a lot more leeway to trade as long as you don't go crazy with maximum trading size. :)
 
Quote from nazzdack:

1) That's a mathematical "deception". Arithmetically, it seems easiest to pass because of its "lower" profit goal. :eek:
2) You're underestimating how "close and near" the daily and overall loss limits are with the 30K. When you become funded, the weekly loss limit becomes another "burden" too. :cool:
3) The loss limits on the 100K and 150K are "more valuable" after you become funded. You have a lot more leeway to trade as long as you don't go crazy with maximum trading size. :)

I wasn't looking at when you become funded I was looking at the ease of passing the combine.

But you are right the daily loss limit of a 30K is 1.67% of capital as compared to 2% for the 150K combine.

However the max drawdown for 30k is 5% of capital as compared to only 3% on the 150K
 
once again, the people selling the shovels to the gold miners are making the big money.

the gold diggers are hoping for fortunes, and leave broke.

i'm starting a combine!!!

$1,000 per hopeful trader. this is your chance to become rich.

I figure I will get 95,000 from the 95% that lose. and then quickly fire the 5% that pass if they lose 0.00001% of my cash.
 
Quote from igotcash:

once again, the people selling the shovels to the gold miners are making the big money.

the gold diggers are hoping for fortunes, and leave broke.

i'm starting a combine!!!

$1,000 per hopeful trader. this is your chance to become rich.

I figure I will get 95,000 from the 95% that lose. and then quickly fire the 5% that pass if they lose 0.00001% of my cash.

Dude, these guys aren't making jack. Riddle me this, if THIS enterprise was so profitable, then why aren't 50 firms replicating this model? Yes, this is an IQ test. It's pass/fail. Better go over your final answer a few times before you post it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top