1/4% Tax on all stock trades pushed in NY Times today

CNBC.com Article: The Robin Hood Tax Won’t Work

The idea of imposing a small tax on financial transactions is gaining popularity around the world. It’s even got a catchy nickname: the Robin Hood tax.

Full Story:
http://www.cnbc.com/id/45583134

Several good new points against FTT. Synthetics or new derivatives risk to evade FTT. Market maker inventory risk. Too big to fail risk. Transferring taxes to rich countries with leading money-centers and more.
 
The suggestion here is that the Tories should toughen Cameron's spine, or someone like Boris Johnson will.

Cameron should cease his horse-trading language and grow some real backbone on this, or he might find his position under challenge from within.

---www.thisislondon.co.uk/standard/article-24019074-boris-johnson-leads-revolt-against-cameron-on-eu-referendum.do

"The government opposes any transactions tax that applies to the City of London but the PM's spokesman said, if it was limited to the 17 eurozone countries: "It certainly doesn't seem obvious to me that that is a threat to the City of London." (Weak).

At Prime Minister's Questions, Mr Cameron faced questions from a stream of Conservative MPs who attacked any further integration in Europe".

More- ---www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-16063911
 
Quote from justrading:

"The leaders of France and Germany have called jointly for eurozone countries to have common corporation and financial transaction taxes.

The tax policy would apply initially to the 17-member eurozone."

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-16075890

Can someone explain how the EU can impose the FTT on EZ-17 members Malta and Luxembourg, both of whom have stated clearly that they will only participate in the FTT if it's global.

Malta and Luxembourg would see a significant part of their financial markets relocate to Switzerland and/or the UK if there was a EZ-17 FTT.
 
Darn, FTT may be becoming a political football in the EU and EZ, like the Bush-era tax cuts are back home in the U.S.

I fear some core-EZ members who are working closely on the fiscal-union strategies - Germany, France and Italy - may forge ahead with FTT in their own national budgets first, to start the snow ball rolling down the hill.

New Italian Premier Mario Monti just included FTT in his new crisis-era austerity and budget measures. France just put FTT on its bill agenda too. And, Germany may do the same next. They want to demonstrate that they are willing to take the heat and pass FTT even if it’s not EU-wide or EZ-wide. Plus, they can keep the tax revenues this way too. They don't have big money-centers and probably can weather the FTT carnage, whereas London cannot. If Cameron is ever boxed into FTT, he should keep all the tax revenue for the UK and not share it with the EU. That's a good rebuttal for him.

The cabal’s plan may be that after the core passes FTT individually in their own countries first, they can better pressure less-favorable EZ members to pass FTT in the entire EZ-17. With that request, they offer up the FTT revenues to support EZ bailout measures and charitable requests, rather than keeping it for their home country treasuries.

If EU-27 or EZ-17 countries don't vote yes on the treaty changes for the new fiscal-union penalties, which may now be added-on to with FTT measures, then Franco-German-Italian forces may threaten the abstainers with no bailouts or support if contagion reaches their sovereign bond markets. How they can do that legally or based on treaties, remains to be seen.

But, we are now down to hardball tactics, and what we experienced in the U.S. with the debt-ceiling debate and hostage taking measures may be just a warm-up act to this euro crisis and stand-off negotiations.

Yes, Cameron needs to hold firm, he is carrying our no-FTT flame. U.S. Secretary Geithner will probably support Cameron on this front, and withhold the U.S.-heavy IMF bazooka funds, since Geithner doesn't want the FTT snow-ball either.

It sort of feels like this snowball is more like German tanks starting to rollover Europe again, with Italian and defeated-French axis members. Same old playbook, the UK is the lone island of freedom, and I hope the U.S. doesn't wait too long before entering this battle. It's time for Secretary Geithner and President Obama to take off their kid gloves with the Germans and draw U.S./UK allies lines in the quick sand too. Be firm on no FTT, opening the ECB bank, and handling the EU bailouts inside the EU. Say a firm no to the IMF taking a leading role, as the American taxpayer is at risk for 17%. The U.S. is helping enough with the Federal Reserve already. Obama is tough on Republicans, how about bringing some of that toughness to the Germans too?
 
New Italian Premier Mario Monti just included FTT in his new crisis-era austerity and budget measures. France just put FTT on its bill agenda too. And, Germany may do the same next. They want to demonstrate that they are willing to take the heat and pass FTT even if it’s not EU-wide or EZ-wide. Plus, they can keep the tax revenues this way too. They don't have big money-centers and probably can weather the FTT carnage, whereas London cannot.

Can they really weather the FTT carnage?

After the swedish experience.. no significant money was raised.

If any small group of countries goes ahead with FTT they will forced to back track within a few years.
 
Quote from southall:

Can they really weather the FTT carnage?

After the swedish experience.. no significant money was raised.

If they any small group of countries goes ahead with FTT they will forced to back track within a few years.

No, FTT will sink them, but they figure they are already sunk.
 
Quote from southall:

Can they really weather the FTT carnage?

After the swedish experience.. no significant money was raised.

If they any small group of countries goes ahead with FTT they will forced to back track within a few years.

One thing to remember in the history of failed societies and guberments, is that when things start to look like the end, guberments will rape and pillage the people and tax and destroy the hell outta themselves.

i.e. Europe right now (but the US is not far behind, so this will always be on the table)

Also, this is not a economic policy as much as it is a political policy of liberal democrat socialists against capitalism and free markets. Remember that and be vigilant.
 
Quote from kalinka:

As a swede knowing swedish politics, our prime- or finance minister will never say yes to a FTT.

Anders Borg has been steadfast thoughout the FTT debate.

I'm sure a lot of pressure has been applied to get him to change his position, but he's never wavered for even one moment. He deserves a medal.
 
Back
Top